RE: 如何正确客观评价历史人物 How to Evaluate Historical Personage Correctly and Objectively
@rivalhw :D
Today, I want to share this content, you may feel more boring, especially women (there is absolutely no discrimination in the meaning of women), generally do not like history, but if you patience to read, I believe you will go How to correctly and objectively view a historical figure, inspired and thought.
Recently read a book, read a section yesterday, is on the historical figures Yuan Shikai evaluation, with my limited historical knowledge, I think the evaluation is more objective and fair.
Usually the history book is such a description of Yuan:
First, Yuan Shikai steal the revolutionary fruit. If he did not appear, Sun Yat-sen and others will be able to successfully establish a bourgeois democratic republic.
Second, Yuan Shikai character is not kind, is a white face Cao Cao, bullying his widow and orphans, overturned Qing court boat.
Most of the views held by modern people, including our textbooks and history books are described so. Next we analyze the following:
Point one, Yuan Shikai steal the revolutionary fruit;
"First of all, in China in 1912, only Yuan Shikai a person, have the real strength and ability to make the" Republic of China "become a reality, not only the powers to see this, constitutionalists to see this, Wuchang Xinhai leaders see this, even Sun Yat-sen , Huang Xing, Wang Ching-wei such revolutionaries are also so to see (no matter how reluctant the revolutionaries, they must also acknowledge this fact.) Li Yuanhong called Yuan Shikai is "looking at the Chinese and foreign, talented people", not all flattery At that time, if the hands of real power, living in the high position of Yuan Shikai does not come out to solve the problem of the abdication of the Qing Dynasty, the whole of China, will be caught in the sea of hard work, is likely to evolve into the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom since the second national In the case of words, it will make the country 's strength more and more.
View two, Yuan Shikai character is not kind, is a white face Cao Cao, bullied his widow and orphans, overturned Qing court boat.
"For the rule, oppression of China's 260 years of the Qing Dynasty royal family, Yuan Shikai's actions, can be described as Daren Dade, extremely good and kind of ability.He not only strive for the Forbidden City to waste Emperor Pu Yi and his family to live every year also dial a large sum of money If you do not have the military strongman of Yuan Shikai, according to the unspoken rules of the Chinese-style dynasty, these "Jue Luo" who must be destroyed by the nine clan, no re-relics! (Finally, Pu Yi from the palace Is the "thousands of generals," Feng Yuxiang, not Yuan Shikai) again, to bloodthirsty, treacherous, tragic start of the royal family, more than two hundred years, the people knock on the blood sucking, killing and killing, exhausted and fishing, bad things to do. But also weak its roots, and finally the Han Chinese helmets in the forehead rally, restore the Chinese. Fortunately, in the era of chaos should have Yuan Shikai such a coincidence at the right time there are carefully prepared political giants, at the critical moment of history Gave the last key push of the Qing court, to the expense of bleeding at the expense of the heavy dragon flag.
I am here to explain these, do not want to go to Yuan Shikai overturned, in fact, Yuan Shikai before the end of some practices, change the reunification for the monarchy, which is clearly in vain reverse Even if the past ten thousand years, but also after all, is stupid and wrong behavior, stupid is stupid, it will not change with time and change, this is the fact that no one can change.
thank you very much,@sdilan