Will Governments Make Bitcoin Illegal? (And Other Cryptocurrencies)steemCreated with Sketch.

in #bitcoin8 years ago (edited)

Bitcoin has been surging lately, only I'm not just referring to the price. The popularity and media exposure of the cryptocurrency has also been surging, as of late. This attention its received is largely due to the fact Bitcoin, and other cryptocurrencies, are something the world has never seen before.
(Feel free to watch the video, or continue reading down below)

Regardless of your feelings on cryptocurrencies, the fact remains that they pose an serious threat to the future of the world's fiat currencies. Sure, they share some problems with fiat currencies. The main one that matters to me, as well as fellow silver and gold investors, is that the asset itself has no real, tangible wealth. Instead, the value of cryptos, such as Bitcoin, are determined by the value people put on them, and the utility they have as a means of exchange. However, don't get me wrong. Cryptocurrencies still have many advantages over fiat currencies. In fact, the threat they pose to the dollar, pound, euro, yen, etc., is the number on reason I've softened up to the idea of cryptos.


How Fiat Works

This changed, when I heard precious metals analyst, Andy Hoffman, refer to precious metals and cryptos as "The Twin Destroyers of the Fiat Regime." I began to see the threat they posed to fiat currencies, and I've since warmed up to them considerably. Among these advantages, is that because of the blockchain technology they are built upon, there is often higher levels of anonymity. Paradoxically, this anonymity also goes hand in hand with high levels of transparency.

The most important attribute of cryptocurrencies, is that they are generally not centralized, but rather, they are decentralized. Sure, they may have creators or developers, but they are not issued by a central government or central bank. Furthermore, most of these cryptos have limits on how much currency can be created at once. Some, such as Bitcoin, put a limit on the total amount that can ever be created. This is the opposite of the fiat currencies of the world, which are issued by a central government entity. Furthermore, there is no limit on how much currency can be created. The Federal Reserve can create trillions of dollars out of thin air (they have). In fact, in theory, they could even create money without necessarily making it public. They can destroy the purchasing power of their citizens, without them even knowing.

Getting to the main question, will governments make cryptocurrencies illegal? Yes, without a doubt, I think some governments around the world will restrict these currencies. However, it may not occur in every jurisdiction, and the level of regulation will vary.

The premise for these regulations and/or prohibitions, will be three things, in my opinion. The government will make the case that cryptos are used to fund terrorism, facilitate drug and/or human trafficking, and allow people to dodge taxes. The first two reasons are most likely, because they tug on the heart strings of Americans. It's very unlikely that they publicly say that it is about protecting their Monopoly money monopoly (think about it).

There are a variety of different regulations that could put on cryptos, without outright banning them. However, make no mistake, any significant regulation will undermine the currency as a whole. The first regulation, that I believe will happen quite soon in the United States and Western Europe, will be a requirement to register your wallet. For most owners, this is easily accomplished by their hosting service, such as Coinbase. By doing so, some level of anonymity no longer exists. Yes, individuals could disobey this order. However, unfortunately, most would obey the law. This would make transfers between registered and unregistered wallets, quite risky for the "legal" individual.

The next level of regulation, which is largely impossible without anonymity removed, is taxation. As far as I know, profits on cryptos are only taxable if the individual takes them out of cryptos altogether. I suspect that this will change. If you profited in a new altcoin, and you want to park your profits in Bitcoin, I believe the government will begin treating that as a taxable investment profit. I'm not convinced the government is all that interested in this small chunk of revenue; I think they would institute such regulations in an attempt to squash high amounts of fiat being traded in for cryptocurrencies. To that end, I think it is possible that countries such as China, would limit the amount an individual could transfer into cryptocurrencies, in a certain time frame.

The final step is to ban cryptocurrencies altogether. I believe that this likely will not begin in the United States. Instead, more authoriarian countries, such as China, India, Russia, and some Middle Eastern countries will be first. (A few smaller countries have already made Bitcoin illegal). My money is on China being the first. However, I think some European countries will soon follow suit. Eventually, I would not at all be surprised to see the United States ban these currencies. Of course, we can hope that, if this happens, it is only proof that fiat currencies are on the verge of total collapse. A ban would have serious consequences on the market. Use would drop significantly, since becoming a felon in order to buy Bitcoin, would likely not be a mainstream idea (yet).

Cryptocurrencies are at a strange juncture. With the more popularity they gain, the more likely it is they will be regulated. However, as they grow, it becomes more likely a ban would be ineffective or widely unpopular. As much as proponents of cryptos try to grow the market, I believe most growth, going forward, will be organic. There are billions of people looking to flee fiat currencies, they just don't all know it yet. Some will go to cryptos, some will go to precious metals. Some will go to both. But make no mistake, the days of fiat currency are numbered.

Image Sources: https://docs.google.com/document/d/12MnbCggmQSbzgN6d2XBQADJre41ezJ9q3R3F1W7y0Jc/edit?usp=sharing

Sort:  

Thanks for your post, very informative and detailed! Personally, I don't think controlling crytocurrency is that easy as it is very much an internet thing and monitoring the internet has not been an easy thing. Even the government can monitor the internet like the US and China did, it does not mean they can regulate them

Great post !
I can't wait until they recognize bitcoin in my country...
frankly, if there is some case that bitcoin is not legal in here,and i'm a "bitcoin millionaire".... i see myself and my family moving to Japan or any other country that is Bitcoin friendly

As far as I know, anyone can write a wallet. All a wallet is is an interface to the blockchain ledger. IMO, registering wallets won't work for them. People would write their own. Wallets on exchanges and coinbase, yeah, they could register those, but people who didn't want to be registered would simply stop using those services. Decentralized exchanges are being created as we speak. We could use those. Not to mention people who get their coins from mining. No way to register the transfer from the network to your account.

They also poker would be banned in other countries before the united states. I believe it will be banned in the USA first. Its not just the problem with fiat currencies but also people trying to get in money they made illegally selling drugs into banks. They already are doing a crack down on exchanges. Bitcoin is no longer decentralized. If you think it is your delusional. I sold all of mine already. Its not what it was a few years ago. To much regulation not on the coin itself but the exchanges that sell them. 90% of the investors are from china. Most are novice investors with no clue about investing. It was a great investment a few years ago. I love the technology but believing any of it is decentralized is just what government wants you to think. They already took down silk roads and alphabay 2 decentralized exchanges. If they can take them down they are not decentralized anymore. They know to make it centralized. Governments will make bitcoin, gold and silver illegal again and take it away from society just like they done before. Your can't go against the government and think your going to out due them and get rich living in their country. Wont ever happen. May for awhile but sooner or later they will throw down regulation and start confiscating as they always do. The best way to make money is to invest in businesses built around helping the economy and government. Not things trying to hurt.

Nice Rab C. Nesbitt picture by the way :)

I think there are more immediate threats to crypto than government regulation/taxation.
1/ The spate of ICOs has significant possibility of causing damage to the credibility of the crypto space if (more likely when) they fail and go pop, all the new investor money that has been sucked into them is going to get scared off, possibly leaving crypto as a fringe place for nutters.
2/ Big businesses co-opt block-chain into closed systems like hyperledger, and this is where all the investment funding starts flowing to.

So for me government issues are only likely if the other two fail to cause significant limitations to crypto-currency growth. The way I see to battle the terror/criminality arguments is through altruistic coins like Gridcoin and SolarCoin, that you can show actually do something positive. The EU Parliament have been presented SolarCoin and liked it.

Also for governments there is the major possibility of offloading a lot of burden onto cryptocurrencies, a lot of admin and beurocracy can go away, and many governments want less friction on trade, so non-national currencies may have a place.

So if crypto doesnt commit suicide, and isnt sidelined by big business, and if it aproaches government with ready made methods to improve their operations in socially responsible ways, then there might be a bright future.

Great Steem Article my friend!
Your friend, Platastacker

Government can do whatever it wants, drugs are illegal too and we're in the middle of a sharp increase in overdose deaths. The beauty of NOT Bitcoin, but good cryptos like Dash and PIVX, is anonymous transactions. Best of luck to the IRS sorting out the obfuscation/coin mixing and zero-knowledge proofs these bring to the table.

I don't know. Nevada in the U.S. recently passed legislation that was pro cryptocurreny and many countries are looking towards ether to build digital fiat currencies on that platform. I could see a world where bitcoin is kind of like "cash" back in the day where people used it for many small purchases and it was widely accepted but major financial institutions will lean on blockchain technology like ethereum as humanity eventually transitions to complete decentralization of currency. Like all good things it will take time.

I hope you're right.

This is my biggest fear!