We have the Amazon Dot, but it's not being used that much. My wife is disappointed we can't just play any music on it, but I'm not sure about paying every month for that privilege. I think it's much the same with the Google devices. I have all my music on the PC, so I need something that will play that easily. I did get some integration with Alexa and our Home Assistant automation so I could lights on and off, but I need to play with that some more.