trennya menyebalkan!
Ya, memang, selalu. Bot belum mengubah itu, itu hanya mengubah siapa yang bisa sampai di sana. Alih-alih segelintir paus dan memilih beberapa teman dari ikan paus, semua orang memiliki akses ke tren. Seperti halnya sebelum bot bidding, semua orang masih memiliki akses ke penandaan, tapi hei siapa yang menandai kan? Jika Anda mendengarkan idiot ini tidak ada.

Saya menyebutnya omong kosong, bid bot lebih dari 50% dan itulah yang akan saya sampaikan kepada semua orang.
Terserah Anda, tidak pernah benar-benar ada banyak kebenaran di Steemit, jauh lebih mudah untuk membuat omong kosong daripada melakukan riset.

Buktikan itu
Pertama saya mendapat daftar semua bot penawaran di situs SteemBotTracker @ yabapmatt melalui endpoint / bid_bots.

Ini memberi saya daftar ini:

buildawhale
bumerang
minnowhelper
lovejuice
sneaky-ninja
penilai
pushup
aksdwi
msp-bidbot
upme
postpromoter
tinggal di atas
allaz
smartsteem
merkuribot
upmewhale
tanpa tidur
steemblogger
adriatik
seakraken
pemilih
bid4joy
nado.bot
saham
whalebuilder
redlambo
inciter
therising
luckyvotes
postdoctor
brupvoter
isotonik
chronocrypto
spydo
onlyprofitbot
mitsuko
sunrawhale
foxyd
honestbot
upboater
promobot
ebargains
setiap hari
bluebot
estream.studios
singing.beauty
megabot
slimwhale
petir
pendorong
thebot
minnowvote
estabond
rocky1
dolphinbot
lost-ninja
redwhale
noicebot
flymehigh
authors.league
brandonfrye
sepatu perdamaian
fishbaitbot
bodzila
lrd
proffit
emperorofnaps
dlivepromoter
pushbot
ubot
steemerap
profitvote
penjual kubis
siditech
otomatisasi
ecotrain
themoneytree
profitbot
whalecreator
botox
oceanwhale
edensgarden
tertanggung
th3voter
ptbot
sureshot
stef
moneymatchgaming
t50
francophonie
votepower
peoplebot
steemcreators
joeparys
whalepromobot
alfanso
haveaheart
persaudaraan
tainika
pwrup
upyourpost
jerrybanfield
boinger
a-bot
pasukan sekutu
weupvote
getkarma
chronoboost
Bagi yang ingin tahu, ada 108 bot bid.

Saya kemudian menambahkan minnowbooster karena terdaftar di bawah bot promosi dan bukan bot bid.

Saya kemudian mengambil daftar ini dan menjalankan dua pertanyaan di SteemSQL. Yang pertama memberi saya total Steem Power yang dialokasikan untuk menawar bot dalam daftar ini. Formulanya sederhana, Steem Power + Delegation In - Delegation Out.

pilih sum (cast (substring (vesting_shares, 1, CHARINDEX ('', vesting_shares) -1) sebagai Desimal (20,6)))

• sum (cast (substring (receive_vesting_shares, 1, CHARINDEX ('', receive_vesting_shares) -1) sebagai Desimal (20,6)))

• sum (cast (substring (delegated_vesting_shares, 1, CHARINDEX ('', delegated_vesting_shares) -1) sebagai Desimal (20,6)))
  dari akun
  dimana nama di (
  'buildawhale',
  'bumerang',
  'minnowbooster',
  'minnowhelper',
  'lovejuice',
  'licik-ninja',
  'Berarti',
  'pushup',
  'aksdwi',
  'msp-bidbot',
  'upme',
  'postpromoter',
  'upgoater',
  'allaz',
  'smartsteem',
  'merkuribot',
  'upmewhale',
  'sleeplesswhale',
  'steemblogger',
  'adriatik',
  'seakraken',
  'voterunner',
  'bid4joy',
  'nado.bot',
  'berbagi',
  'whalebuilder',
  'redlambo',
  'inciter',
  'therising',
  'luckyvotes',
  'postdoctor',
  'brupvoter',
  'isotonik',
  'Chronocrypto',
  'spydo',
  'onlyprofitbot',
  'mitsuko',
  'sunrawhale',
  'foxyd',
  'honestbot',
  'upboater',
  'promobot',
  'ebargains',
  'dailyupvotes',
  'bluebot',
  'estream.studios',
  'singing.beauty',
  'megabot',
  'langsing',
  'petir',
  'pendorong',
  'thebot',
  'minnowvotes',
  'estabond',
  'rocky1',
  'dolphinbot',
  'lost-ninja',
  'redwhale',
  'noicebot',
  'flymehigh',
  'authors.league',
  'brandonfrye',
  'damai-bot',
  'fishbaitbot',
  'bodzila',
  'lrd',
  'proffit',
  'emperorofnaps',
  'dlivepromoter',
  'pushbot',
  'ubot',
  'steemerap',
  'profitvote',
  'pedagang kubis',
  'siditech',
  'otomatisasi',
  'Ecotrain',
  'themoneytree',
  'profitbot',
  'whalecreator',
  'botox',
  'oceanwhale',
  'edensgarden',
  'Tertanggung',
  'Th3voter',
  'ptbot',
  'sureshot',
  'stef',
  'moneymatchgaming',
  't50',
  'francophonie',
  'votepower',
  'peoplebot',
  'steemcreators',
  'joeparys',
  'Whalepromobot',
  'alfanso',
  'haveaheart',
  'persaudaraan',
  'tainika',
  'pwrup',
  'upyourpost',
  'jerrybanfield',
  'boinger',
  'a-bot',
  'Kekuatan sekutu',
  'weupvote',
  'getkarma',
  'chronoboost'
  )
  Ini memberi saya hasil dari 43.124.045.125.085064 Rompi.

1.000.000 rompi setara 492.539 Steem, jadi itu berarti 21.240.294.1576 Steem Power dikendalikan oleh bot.

Selanjutnya, kita perlu menemukan berapa banyak Steem Power tidak dikontrol oleh bot.

Menjalankan kueri yang sama tetapi mengecualikan kumpulan data sebelumnya akan memberi kita sisa dari komunitas.

pilih sum (cast (substring (vesting_shares, 1, CHARINDEX ('', vesting_shares) -1) sebagai Desimal (20,6)))

• sum (cast (substring (receive_vesting_shares, 1, CHARINDEX ('', receive_vesting_shares) -1) sebagai Desimal (20,6)))

• sum (cast (substring (delegated_vesting_shares, 1, CHARINDEX ('', delegated_vesting_shares) -1) sebagai Desimal (20,6)))
  dari akun
  di mana nama tidak ada di (
  'buildawhale',
  'bumerang',
  'minnowbooster',
  'minnowhelper',
  'lovejuice',
  'licik-ninja',
  'Berarti',
  'pushup',
  'aksdwi',
  'msp-bidbot',
  'upme',
  'postpromoter',
  'upgoater',
  'allaz',
  'smartsteem',
  'merkuribot',
  'naik

image.png
Another day, another post asking how much Steem Power is behind bid bots and how they are the death of Steem.

But I thought it was over 50%?
Nope. Not even close.

But trending sucks!
Yes, it does, always has. Bots haven't changed that, it just changed who can get there. Instead of a handful of whales and select few friends of the whales, everyone has access to trending. Like before bid bots, everyone still has access to flagging, but hey who flags right? If you listen to this idiot no one.

I call bullshit, bid bots are more than 50% and that's what I'm going to tell everyone.
Suit yourself, there has never really been much truth on Steemit, it's far easier to just make shit up than do the research.

Prove it then
First I got a list of all the bid bots on @yabapmatt's SteemBotTracker site via the /bid_bots endpoint.

This gave me this list:

buildawhale
boomerang
minnowhelper
lovejuice
sneaky-ninja
appreciator
pushup
aksdwi
msp-bidbot
upme
postpromoter
upgoater
allaz
smartsteem
mercurybot
upmewhale
sleeplesswhale
steembloggers
adriatik
seakraken
voterunner
bid4joy
nado.bot
shares
whalebuilder
redlambo
inciter
therising
luckyvotes
postdoctor
brupvoter
isotonic
chronocrypto
spydo
onlyprofitbot
mitsuko
sunrawhale
foxyd
honestbot
upboater
promobot
ebargains
dailyupvotes
bluebot
estream.studios
singing.beauty
megabot
slimwhale
lightningbolt
booster
thebot
minnowvotes
estabond
rocky1
dolphinbot
lost-ninja
redwhale
noicebot
flymehigh
authors.league
brandonfrye
peace-bot
fishbaitbot
bodzila
lrd
proffit
emperorofnaps
dlivepromoter
pushbot
ubot
steemerap
profitvote
cabbage-dealer
siditech
automation
ecotrain
themoneytree
profitbot
whalecreator
botox
oceanwhale
edensgarden
bearwards
th3voter
ptbot
sureshot
stef
moneymatchgaming
t50
francophonie
votepower
peoplesbot
steemcreators
joeparys
whalepromobot
alfanso
haveaheart
brotherhood
tainika
pwrup
upyourpost
jerrybanfield
boinger
a-bot
alliedforces
weupvote
getkarma
chronoboost
For those who are wondering, there are 108 bid bots.

I then added minnowbooster because it listed under promotional bots and not bid bots.

I then took this list and ran two queries on SteemSQL. The first gives me the total Steem Power allocated to bid bots in this list. The formula is simple, Steem Power + Delegation In - Delegation Out.

select sum(cast(substring(vesting_shares, 1, CHARINDEX(' ', vesting_shares)-1) as Decimal(20,6)))

• sum(cast(substring(received_vesting_shares, 1, CHARINDEX(' ', received_vesting_shares)-1) as Decimal(20,6)))

• sum(cast(substring(delegated_vesting_shares, 1, CHARINDEX(' ', delegated_vesting_shares)-1) as Decimal(20,6)))
  from accounts
  where name in (
  'buildawhale',
  'boomerang',
  'minnowbooster',
  'minnowhelper',
  'lovejuice',
  'sneaky-ninja',
  'appreciator',
  'pushup',
  'aksdwi',
  'msp-bidbot',
  'upme',
  'postpromoter',
  'upgoater',
  'allaz',
  'smartsteem',
  'mercurybot',
  'upmewhale',
  'sleeplesswhale',
  'steembloggers',
  'adriatik',
  'seakraken',
  'voterunner',
  'bid4joy',
  'nado.bot',
  'shares',
  'whalebuilder',
  'redlambo',
  'inciter',
  'therising',
  'luckyvotes',
  'postdoctor',
  'brupvoter',
  'isotonic',
  'chronocrypto',
  'spydo',
  'onlyprofitbot',
  'mitsuko',
  'sunrawhale',
  'foxyd',
  'honestbot',
  'upboater',
  'promobot',
  'ebargains',
  'dailyupvotes',
  'bluebot',
  'estream.studios',
  'singing.beauty',
  'megabot',
  'slimwhale',
  'lightningbolt',
  'booster',
  'thebot',
  'minnowvotes',
  'estabond',
  'rocky1',
  'dolphinbot',
  'lost-ninja',
  'redwhale',
  'noicebot',
  'flymehigh',
  'authors.league',
  'brandonfrye',
  'peace-bot',
  'fishbaitbot',
  'bodzila',
  'lrd',
  'proffit',
  'emperorofnaps',
  'dlivepromoter',
  'pushbot',
  'ubot',
  'steemerap',
  'profitvote',
  'cabbage-dealer',
  'siditech',
  'automation',
  'ecotrain',
  'themoneytree',
  'profitbot',
  'whalecreator',
  'botox',
  'oceanwhale',
  'edensgarden',
  'bearwards',
  'th3voter',
  'ptbot',
  'sureshot',
  'stef',
  'moneymatchgaming',
  't50',
  'francophonie',
  'votepower',
  'peoplesbot',
  'steemcreators',
  'joeparys',
  'whalepromobot',
  'alfanso',
  'haveaheart',
  'brotherhood',
  'tainika',
  'pwrup',
  'upyourpost',
  'jerrybanfield',
  'boinger',
  'a-bot',
  'alliedforces',
  'weupvote',
  'getkarma',
  'chronoboost'
  )
  This gives me the result of 43,124,045,125.085064 Vests.

1,000,000 vests equal 492.539 Steem, so that means 21,240,294.1576 Steem Power is controlled by bots.

Next, we need to find how much Steem Power is not controlled by bots.

Running the same query but excluding the previous data set will give us the rest of the community.

select sum(cast(substring(vesting_shares, 1, CHARINDEX(' ', vesting_shares)-1) as Decimal(20,6)))

• sum(cast(substring(received_vesting_shares, 1, CHARINDEX(' ', received_vesting_shares)-1) as Decimal(20,6)))

• sum(cast(substring(delegated_vesting_shares, 1, CHARINDEX(' ', delegated_vesting_shares)-1) as Decimal(20,6)))
  from accounts
  where name not in (
  'buildawhale',
  'boomerang',
  'minnowbooster',
  'minnowhelper',
  'lovejuice',
  'sneaky-ninja',
  'appreciator',
  'pushup',
  'aksdwi',
  'msp-bidbot',
  'upme',
  'postpromoter',
  'upgoater',
  'allaz',
  'smartsteem',
  'mercurybot',
  'upmewhale',
  'sleeplesswhale',
  'steembloggers',
  'adriatik',
  'seakraken',
  'voterunner',
  'bid4joy',
  'nado.bot',
  'shares',
  'whalebuilder',
  'redlambo',
  'inciter',
  'therising',
  'luckyvotes',
  'postdoctor',
  'brupvoter',
  'isotonic',
  'chronocrypto',
  'spydo',
  'onlyprofitbot',
  'mitsuko',
  'sunrawhale',
  'foxyd',
  'honestbot',
  'upboater',
  'promobot',
  'ebargains',
  'dailyupvotes',
  'bluebot',
  'estream.studios',
  'singing.beauty',
  'megabot',
  'slimwhale',
  'lightningbolt',
  'booster',
  'thebot',
  'minnowvotes',
  'estabond',
  'rocky1',
  'dolphinbot',
  'lost-ninja',
  'redwhale',
  'noicebot',
  'flymehigh',
  'authors.league',
  'brandonfrye',
  'peace-bot',
  'fishbaitbot',
  'bodzila',
  'lrd',
  'proffit',
  'emperorofnaps',
  'dlivepromoter',
  'pushbot',
  'ubot',
  'steemerap',
  'profitvote',
  'cabbage-dealer',
  'siditech',
  'automation',
  'ecotrain',
  'themoneytree',
  'profitbot',
  'whalecreator',
  'botox',
  'oceanwhale',
  'edensgarden',
  'bearwards',
  'th3voter',
  'ptbot',
  'sureshot',
  'stef',
  'moneymatchgaming',
  't50',
  'francophonie',
  'votepower',
  'peoplesbot',
  'steemcreators',
  'joeparys',
  'whalepromobot',
  'alfanso',
  'haveaheart',
  'brotherhood',
  'tainika',
  'pwrup',
  'upyourpost',
  'jerrybanfield',
  'boinger',
  'a-bot',
  'alliedforces',
  'weupvote',
  'getkarma',
  'chronoboost'
  )
  The result is 344,466,605,247.887549 Vests, or 169,663,397.8027 Steem Power.
  image.png

All that is left now is to determine what percentage of total Steem Power is 21,240,294.1576 Steem Power.

21,240,294.1576 (21,240,294.1576 + 169,663,397.8027) = 11.112%.

This number will change a little when you factor in bots who execute votes via a users account (like MinnowBooster and SteemMarket) but won't be too far off.

wltz.gif

X48EJ
Why you should vote me as witness

Witness & Administrator of four full nodes
Active, Present, Passionate

My recent popular posts
STEEM, STEEM Power, Vests, and Steem Dollars. wtf is this shit?
The truth and lies about 25% curation, why what you know is FAKE NEWS
WTF is a hardware wallet, and why should you have one?
GINABOT - The Secret to your Sanity on Steemit
How to calculate post rewards
Use SSH all the time? Time for a big boy SSH Client
How to change your recovery account
How curation rewards work and how to be a kick ass curator
Markdown 101 - How to make kick ass posts on Steemit
Work ON your business, not in your business! - How to succeed as a small business
You are not entitled to an audience, you need to earn it!
How to properly setup SSH Key Authentication - If you are logging into your server with root, you are doing it wrong!
Building a Portable Game Console