You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: Contest | 25-Word-Comment - Monkey Business | Prizes Divided - 6 Steem
Ada satu pertanyaan tentang plagiat, jika saya menulis suatu pendapat yang berasal dari para ahli tanpa menyebutkan sumbernya dan kebetulan pakar tersebut tidak terkenal, apakah penyelenggara kontes mengetahuinya?
A good question also what is Plagiarism? Is the use of idioms plagiarism? Someone was the first using these words. Is citing a phrase of the holy book plagiarism? Are ideas not mine and mentioning them theft or plagiarism? Where exactly is the line? How many expressiins, memes are words expressed by someone else? Commercial makers, actors, poets, standup comedians and even if they said them are these words original theirs or did a 3 year old say them, a columnist?
Is saying "they say" enough to make clear these are not your words but someone else's?
Benar sekali, mereka cukup menyebutkan dari mana mereka mengutip itu sudah menjelaskan semuanya tanpa harus menampilkan detail dari link berita.
Kedengarannya cukup bagus bagi saya.
Sebenarnya kita bisa mengacu pada notasi lagu yang sudah lebih jelas memberikan batasan. Lagu yang mana bisa di sebut plagiat.
Most songs, words are plagiarism so are films, books but in some way it's allowed. What to think about fairy tales?
I just counted the comments on this contest. About 8 Steemians out of this entire platform dared to reply but those 8 are good enough for over 135 replies. About 50% are mine, your score is high as well. To keep discussions alive answers are important.
Although there is a lot of discussion among the hosts, moderators I wonder if it's worth the time and energy. If only 8 people comment it means 99,999 % doesn't care or scared.
Nah, itu masalah yang steemit alami. Jika kita melihat bagaimana platform sejenis seperti twitter yang begitu aktip berkomentar. Saya tidak paham tujuan para steemian apa hanya sekadar mengumpulkan steem semata, tapi sudahlah itu hak masing-masing steemian.
Terkait dongeng, ini keahlian yang langka. Tapi yang saya khawatirkan jika itu dongeng masa lalu di copy ulang. Jika idenya sama itu tidak menjadi suatu permasalahan dan bukan plagiat karena gaya penulisnya pasti berbeda.
All the tales here can be told and are rewritten many times. I once read tales like Little Red Riding Hood has hundreds of different versions same for the others.
Those Tales of the brothers Grimm so famous are not theirs. They only wrote them down and never cared about noting the name of the storyteller. They took the credit.
Nah itu dia masalahnya, apa susahnya menulis nama pengarang aslinya, hanya isinya sudah menggunakan versi yang berbeda. Sama seperti penyanyi yang membawakan lagu penyanyi lain maka lagu yang dinyanyikan itu disebut dengan "cover version".