You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Andrew Yang's Siren Song of Free Money Will Cost You Dearly

In this case, the VAT that they will use to either fund or partially fund the UBI is what creates instant inflation in the price of goods and services. Take the UK as an example. When you add a 20% VAT the good or service is immediately transformed at the cash register from £100 to £120. When you figure in every good or service this happens to; things get out of control very quickly.

If a salesman came to your door and offered you $100.00 free every month and all you had to do was sign up for a book club membership which costs $120.00 a month and as a bonus, you got one free book a month up to 10 dollars in value. Then regardless of the fact that you're getting $100.00 in "free money" and one "free book" every month; the truth of the matter is the money ain't free, the book ain't free, and you're out an additional $10.00 a month. With the $120.00 monthly fee, you're paying for it all, and this includes the net loss.

This doesn't even touch on traditional inflation; so for example, let's say the VAT doesn't cover the entire cost of the spending, perhaps the government will subsidize a percentage of the difference for the first 3 years to get everyone on board before they incrementally start jacking up the percent of the VAT to a realistic number that will cover the entire program.

This means the portion government funded which wasn't covered by the VAT will have been covered with new money. Every time government does a spending bill they're borrowing new money from the fed, and that inflates the supply of the currency which eventually trickles down to the prices of goods and services.

The inflation is why you can't get a coke for a nickel anymore like it was for coke's first 70 years of existence, the value of a dollar goes down, and therefore the prices of goods and services go up, the price differential is passed along to the consumer. I don't know how the URV or the real would relate to the value of the federal reserve note. It doesn't seem like a solid comparison, but I hear things aren't going so well in Brazil. The socialism they engaged in set them back quite a bit.

The UBI is like trying to tap into free energy, we all want to believe it's possible, but until we see a working model that doesn't require adding water to get free water, then we'd be foolish to do so at the peril of civilization as we know it.

Sort:  

In this case, the VAT that they will use to either fund or partially fund the UBI is what creates instant inflation in the price of goods and services. Take the UK as an example. When you add a 20% VAT the good or service is immediately transformed at the cash register from £100 to £120. When you figure in every good or service this happens to; things get out of control very quickly.

First you're confusing taxes with inflation. Taxes aren't a form of inflation, they are costs to goods and services.

https://www.differencebetween.com/difference-between-cost-of-living-and-vs-inflation/

The only argument I'll entertain isn't that it'll cause inflation, but that you think it'll guarantee an increase in cost of living.

https://medium.com/basic-income/wouldnt-unconditional-basic-income-just-cause-massive-inflation-fe71d69f15e7

But then again, inflation isn't as simple as you think, and what are you trying to say with something that has nothing to do with how Brazil dealt with their hyperinflation? Ubi has been studied, we know it's effects, it points to the opposite of what you're suggesting, it is not "a peril". You can open your mind, how do you talk about something you seemingly have no clue about? You think you know how inflation works? Why? And how do you come to that conclusion that you have any clue as to how inflation works, money creation or ubi?

Loading...