Can You Prove That Reality Is Real? Spoiler Alert: You Cannot, But There's A Twist!

in #life5 years ago

One of my favorite philosophical concepts is Solipsism.  It's the idea that no matter how hard you try, you can't empirically prove that reality is any more 'real' than a dream.  For all you know, you could be a brain in a jar at a mad scientist's lab, wired up to some computer system that sends feedback signals to your senses.

Okay, the odds are that you're probably not stuck in a mad scientist's brain-jar, but for all practical purposes you may as well be.  The issue arises when we try to define what reality is, and how reality is different from a dream.  But the thing is that a dream is a reflection of reality.

If we say that reality is a dream within a dream then we end up with model of multiple realities shaped sort of like an onion (with layers inside of other layers).  But an onion-shaped reality doesn't explain much, it's just an interesting concept to think of.

A different approach would be to say that no matter how many reflections of a reality there are, they're all essentially reflecting the same thing (just from different angles, and with different degrees of clarity).  When you dream, most of you dream about your life in some way.  Even if you fall asleep inside your dreams and have an entirely different layer of dreaming within a dream, it's still you who's experiencing those dreams.  Even if you dream that there's more than one of you, it's still just you who's dreaming it all.

So then what's out there beyond this reality?  What happens to us when we die?  Well, let me put it to you this way: if the wind can't assemble a functioning CPU out of the raw materials found in a desert, then how do you suppose the winds of fate assembled human consciousness on this planet?  The answer is that you (or at least the thing calling itself 'you') are probably not made from the atoms in this universe.

Your conscious awareness is something that this pixelated cloud of stardust which we call a reality most likely didn't create (it would be as improbable as a dream creating the brain that did the dreaming).  That's why we can't prove that reality isn't a dream, because any experiments we try to do about it would come from inside this reality/dream.  Would you trust the results of a scientific experiment you performed in your sleep?  Maybe while you were still sleeping, but then what?

I said before that the issue was about defining reality, but you can't define reality without recognizing reality's observer (that's you!).  The classical problem with any observer is that the only way to see the part of you that see's is to look into a reflection.  And dreams are a reflection of our consciousness, so maybe the reason why we dream (or even experience 'reality') is to recognize ourselves.

The thing is, even though we can't prove that we're not dreaming, sometimes we can prove that we are dreaming (it's usually when we're asleep, and then eventually we wake up, but that's kind of the point).

Sort:  

Very interesting

Sounds like the movie "Inception".

This information is thought provoking i like it, its special when you jave people who think deep in a world where most people are shallow that's why i followed you keep are the good work i appreciate it have a great day too!!!!

Thank you so much!

First to thank you for all your votes, just now, until all mine become too viral, for that one of the firsts my supporters.
With two things:

  • the dream isn't same as reality, as @hermeticgenetics said, no smell, no forms, also no colors (only insane), no pain, seems to be not real, but just in this reality, not in that, as you said;
  • but, dream, again: with open eyes, with the soul, just as @entertheart21 said: emotions, irrational, the real perception of the real as no time, meaning transcendental way, because you said: observer is you, and try to really feel yourself's nature, your conscious awareness, which you said isn't made from the this reality: the love.

DAMN ! for real i love that POST ! A question that humanity will ask itself for ever

Do you know what that 'phobia' is where people are afraid that reality is like a dream and one day the dreamer will wake up? Because that is kinda true! @anomaly (its funny that you call yourself an anomaly because I have refered to myself as the Hapax Legomenon of life {a hapax legomenon is a word that occurs only once within a context}

This is a fascinating concept: proving the reality we exist in from within said reality.

It generally can only be conceptualized from a perspective outside that reality or perception of it.

Where-in lies my perspective, in that there are multiple ways to perceive this reality and what it means to each of us as individuals.

While I, like many others, cannot personally relate to the ‘dream experience’, it is no less real to those of you that DO dream, than this reality is to all of us.

I certainly could not convince you that you did not dream, since you yourself had the experience of a dream, and are already convinced of its’ having occurred.

My understanding of what people describe as dreams is something much different than what we experience as this reality.
If not for the simple fact that they can tell the difference between when they are dreaming and when they are not, dreams are also described as having a different perception of the 5 senses.
Smells don’t quite smell right, things don’t appear or feel the same. Pain is often described as non-existent in the dream state. “pinch yourself to see if you are awake”, and whatnot.
Events that occur in dreams are often described as unrealistic events.

Not everyone dreams, and not everyone has the same dreams.
Therefore, we can definitively say that dreams are not reality.

For those of us who do not dream, we go to sleep and instantaneously awaken later to find our reality just as intact as we left it. Quite frankly, the thought of having to experience some “non-reality” between the end and beginning of each consecutive day seems like more of a “nightmare” than any scary non-real dreams I have heard people describe.

But what of this reality? The one we all experience together and can, for the most part, agree on aspects of the experience?

For instance, our ability to communicate with one another by various means.
We can send information to one another through any of our 5 primary senses, or even use extensions thereof such as digital communications or radio broadcast.

Is reality real?

Well we first must define what we perceive as reality. At which point we can discuss how real or not real it may or may not be.

If you describe your perception of reality in every minute detail I could only agree up to the point at which your perception of reality differs from my own. Doing this across a wide number of human specimens can give us an idea of the consistencies and inconsistencies in our various perceptions.

But I think the real question is:
Is reality really what we think we are perceiving?

We can feel and object and determine its shape and physical dimensions and in most cases our sense of vision concurs. We can agree on the shape and size of physical objects, and even their weight. I can prove that each of these perceptions is merely subjective and no more real than the dream you claim to have had. But let’s take an example that’s a little easier to understand.

Color

I will exclude for the purpose of discussion, those that we consider color-impaired or those that do not always agree with the common perception of a particular color, and focus on people that do agree.

We can select from various colors a color with an associated nomenclature, let’s say green.
For us, all things green appear to be “green”.
What is green? Well we point at it and say that is green. But what of the actual color each of us see? Do we see the same green? Or do we simply associate whatever color we see as being green because we were told that is green?

The latter is the correct answer. We do not all see the same green, or any color for that matter.
Each eye perceives color differently. But those differences are consistent such that the true color has the same effect when viewed from the same eyes. In other words, we see a color that we associate as green whenever we seen something green, but your green is not the same as my green. And I have no way to communicate to you what those differences are, other than to allow you to see through the lenses of my eye.
Then you can say “oh, that’s what you see as green”. You will quickly want your eyes back because you are used to your own color set.

Each aspect of our perception is experienced differently by each of us. Reality, wether it is real or not, is not exactly what we perceive it to be.

This is a fascinating concept: proving the reality we exist in from within said reality.

This is impossible, because a part of us is made by things outside of our perceptive reality, as he said: The answer is that you (or at least the thing calling itself 'you') are probably not made from the atoms in this universe.

It generally can only be conceptualized from a perspective outside that reality or perception of it.

Very true, do you know that concept? I know it!

Wherein lies my perspective, in that there are multiple ways to perceive this reality and what it means to each of us as individuals.

Yes, this is a big problem as you said all in all this your reply!

While I, like many others, cannot personally relate to the ‘dream experience’, it is no less real to those of you that DO dream, than this reality is to all of us.

I read this ton of times and it would seem opposite than I thought. Until I understood: you said a big thing, that the fact that some of us dream aren't a reason that the reality seems less real to us than the reality is to all of us, but, actually more real (in some circumstances, but I don't say which).

I certainly could not convince you that you did not dream, since you yourself had the experience of a dream, and are already convinced of its’ having occurred.

This has two approaches: one is that only happen to someone woke up from this reality (isn't the case), and two that the real powerful open eyes dreams still cannot convinced isn't, heart way: it would be not nice, divine way it wold can happen for real. Isn't?

nice poste. i see this story is so fascinating and so great and so important that it illustrates a lot of things how dreams we have to get out of them to achieve

I am, that whats left = mirror of erd(e).de <-'global' dream?

Congratulations @anomaly! You have completed the following achievement on the Steem blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

You distributed more than 650000 upvotes. Your next target is to reach 660000 upvotes.

You can view your badges on your Steem Board and compare to others on the Steem Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

To support your work, I also upvoted your post!

Do not miss the last post from @steemitboard:

SteemFest⁴ - Meet the Steemians Contest
Vote for @Steemitboard as a witness to get one more award and increased upvotes!

thank you for your help and support

You're welcome @anomaly
Feel free to support us back: vote for our witness.
You will get one more badge and more powerful upvotes from us on your posts with our next notifications.

New to Steemit?