Jazzday Analysis - What makes my song so horrible, and what can you learn from it?

in #music7 years ago (edited)

This is just a post I felt the need to write for some inexplicable reason.

Recently I was messing around with the few bits of software I had on my new laptop and created this... alternative birthday song. To many of you, you'll listen with horror as the squeaking tones and dissonant harmonies scrape at your eardrums. Others might find it quite an interesting and fun arrangement.

I figure it's a good idea to explain just what's going on so you too can enjoy the masterpiece. (...)

Circle of Fifths

No matter what key your music is in, it will be related to other keys in some way. The Circle of Fifths is a neat way to showcase these relationships and also work as a great tool for songwriting. It looks like this:

I'll avoid going into an actual theory lesson, but you'll notice a few patterns right off the bat:

  • The sharps (#) increase in number as you go clockwise, and the flats (b) increase anticlockwise, where they all meet in a big jumbling mess at 6 O'clock.

  • The notes intervals increase by a fifth going clockwise, and a forth anti-clockwise. Simply put, from C to G, you have C, D, E, F and G = Five notes. From C to F, you only have four.

These features are important to be familiar with. In lots of Jazz - and indeed loads of other music - a progression of chords tend to follow the anti-clockwise path for a short distance to create a very recognizeable sound:



In Clapton's Autumn Leaves (originally by Joseph Kosma, 1945), the chords go as follows: Bm, Em7, A7, Dmaj7, Gmaj7, C#dim, F#7 and back to Bm.

Aside from slight alterations to chords to make them major, minor or diminished (urban defition: very minor) to fit into the key of B minor, the song follows the clock a full 180 degrees around.




This is partly the foundation of the birthday song I made above. Starting in G minor, the track moves to C, F, Bb, Eb, and then finishes with A and D.










So when you remove the melody and break the chords down a bit, you get this:

Parallel motion

There's more movement than static chords, however. There's something called parallel motion which is generally a big no-no in harmonious music. Basically, each note in a chord move up or down in exactly the same motion to the next chord. This is quite grating on our ears for whatever reason and thus is considered 'against the rules' in classical songwriting.

Tritone substitution

A tritone is an interval of 3 whole tones, also known as either a diminished 5th or an augmented 4th. All the same. On the wheel clock, tritones are handily positioned opposite of each other:

These tritone substitutions are simply passing chords that move from one of the main chords to the next main chord in a chromatic style (moving up or down in semi-tones).

Chromaticism is not typically in any key, so this contributes more to the dissonant effect you can hear. Take another listen to the track above and see if you can spot them!

Bitonality

Finally, I moved the tonal centre of the melody up a minor 3rd - from D to F. This means the melody is in the key of F major while the harmonies discussed here are all in the key of D minor. Multiple keys played at the same time are called bi-, or polytonal.

The pleasant Jazz progression

So now that you've heard and understood such a heinous track, my next music post will be a short tune based on the circle of fifths, but I promise to make it sound nice.

@elliotjgardner, you in?

Image sources: credit to Sienna Woode

Sort:  

Shhht...you're teaching AI how to write music when you explain it like that. We have a chance against them in the coming war, but not if they can dazzle us with eulalies.

Not sure if you're aware but they already figured that out!

Don't see this becoming a hit anytime soon. It sounds like a record played backwards to catch Satanic lyrics.

Also, apparently they sampled a lot of my grandparents' generation's songs. Wanna see what they could do with today's.

Playing hard to satisfy eh? How about this hour long movie soundtrack

That's actually quite good!

We're in deep trouble.

Very interesting, will print that image and try it later on :)

A musician and a programmer? I can see some interesting tracks coming outta that combo

Was having fun with propellerhead's Reason.. think it was version 2 or 3???

woah oldskool, I was using reason back in the 3rd edition days! crazy program

I learnt music in secondary but was never taught this much. Thanks for sharing this! Now I see why @bashadow speaks so highly you. I wish to try this someday

Who's that? I don't recall them commenting on any of my posts?

I don’t think I was ever out @mobbs.

heh, loser

I meant to say “Let me check my schedule because I probably don’t have time for this or whatever”

Also, pls finish post before posting.

As a perfectionist, your request is deemed impossible

Any idea why we humans enjoy the sequence of intervals you describe but not some other pattern?

A big part of it is cultural, but it's a pretty huge question. I touch on another aspect here if you're interested in how music is potentially biologically innate, and I'm sure it's no coincidence how things turned out regarding that research

Never knew one could break down music this much; superb analysis. I think I just love some songs without knowing why I like it. For instance, I'm a huge fan of Yanni the jazz man. Maybe I should start paying more attention to music to see if I could decipher why I value some over others.

People often say you shouldn't study the things you love because it saps all the fun out of it and you learn to hate it but it's totally opposite in reality. You learn to appreciate things on a whole different level on top of simply enjoying it. The same applies for music with me. Being able to deconstruct and see into the mind of the creators just makes it all the more wonderful... and also filters out the shit lol

Do you really think or believe that the creators break it down to this level whole making music? Or is it just like some talented people just know how to do things they do without giving it any prior thoughts? I'm all for filtering out the shit though :)

I enjoyed it. I’m going to sing this at birthdays from now on :-) and you provided that nice key art which I need to study!

Ahaha you must be a bitter person, trying to ruin people's birthdays like that!

Wow!
You are dynamic I must say @mobbs
I'm gonna try those cycle of fifth chords on my piano tonight.
Good tutorial.