You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Pilot Wave Theory

in #physics7 years ago

I don't know if I should be relieved to know about Bohmian Mechanics or annoyed.

The same kind of "annoyed" as when I found out about dark energy, as in how can the universe be speeding up, what happened to the conservation of momentum?

Pilot Wave Theory could possibly "annoy" me the same way. But I haven't decided if this is the salvation to my own sanity or exactly the opposite. With Pilot Wave, I don't have to worry about "it" being there and not being there at the same time. (It being all the subatomic particles in the universe.) "It" wouldn't be a particle and at the same time. "It" would behave properly. True, we won't know where "it" is and what "its" velocity is at the same time, but that's okay, that would be because we are not smart enough and can't observe "it" that closely, not because "it" is non-deterministic and rides that probability wave nonsense.

But on the other hand, Pilot Wave has a lot of bad implications as well; such as, the universe is caste in stone and nothing we can do can change it. In that case, might as well crawl back to bed and wallow out our depressed lives in squalor until we drop dead or the universe ends in proton-decay, whichever comes first.

Just my two cents,
Joe

I have equally insane (and inane) stories at @joe.nobel
Science-fiction, modern fantasy, and erotica.
Check them out if you'd care to. No obligation to upvote, follow, or resteem,
just let me know if you enjoy them.

Sort:  

True, we won't know where "it" is and what "its" velocity is at the same time ...

Actually, it's position and momentum that we cannot know at the same time. What's interesting, if you were to force the situation, using the Pauli exclusion principle, the information will still be hidden.

If you squeeze neutrons enough, so that they begin to violate Pauli exclusion (try to get two neutrons to occupy the same space at the same time), they get so close to one another that you can infer the position of one and the momentum of the other, thereby violate Heisenberg uncertainty, guess what happens?

Instead of violating Pauli or Heisenberg, an event horizon forms, which hides the result. Perhaps you could get the information if you yourself enter the event horizon. But you wouldn't be able to tell anyone.

Thanks, but I don't "do" that small, and I kinda like to get back out of whatever I squeeze into so I can tell the world about it.

Whatever lives way down there, it's NOT a particle, and it's NOT a wave. It only behaves like a particle when we some times look then behaves like a wave at other times.
:)
Joe

What I'm describing is a neutron star, so it's large enough to investigate. This is because gravity is the only force that comes close to violating the Pauli exclusion principle for neutrons.

Okay, I thought you were talking about a micro-miniature black hole. My bad.