Pocket Protocol
POCKET Protocol Specification
Please see the POCKET announcement on Steemit and the POCKET Genesis Post.
Introduction
The POCKET, or Proof Of Concept Electronic Token (the K is silent), is a sub-token designed to operate on the Steem blockchain and interact with its users through a simple set of commands which users can invoke via interfaces such as Steemit.com and Busy.org.
Users can transfer POCKET tokens from their account to any other Steem account by including a specially-formatted command in a Steem post (a comment
operation). In order to provide incentives for third parties to maintain copies of the POCKET database, a small fee is taken from each transaction and is paid to the first Steem account which posts a confirmation of the validity of the transaction to the Steem blockchain. This confirmation is posted as a reply to the post which originated the transfer, thus providing users feedback about their actions and making the system useful without an explicit need for 3rd-party block explorers or local client software.
The protocol is designed to be as simple as possible while ensuring robust protections against double-spending.
Purpose of the Protocol
Any blockchain-based cryptocurrency must possess two conceptual elements: a consensus mechanism which generates a blockchain, and a deterministic protocol which translates a history of blockchain operations into record of "who owns what." In many ways, the first is the more difficult problem; however, we consider it to be sufficiently solved by the Steem blockchain. That is, we will consider the Steem blockchain to be an immutable history of messages.
Given the assumption of an immutable Steem blockchain, the POCKET protocol is a specification of the second part of the cryptocurrency problem: it is a deterministic protocol which translates the history of messages in the Steem blockchain into the state of the POCKET system. Users of POCKET can pass messages to the POCKET protocol by including them in properly-formatted Steem transactions.
Note that the POCKET protocol is not owned by anyone. It is not controlled by anyone. Participants in the POCKET system have implicitly agreed that the tokens defined by the protocol have meaning and possibly value; the tokens are not issued by any person or entity.
Database
The core of the POCKET database is a specification of which accounts control which tokens.
A small amount of auxiliary data is stored by the POCKET database as well, and this will be made clear in subsequent sections.
Account
A POCKET account
has two properties:
name
: String corresponding to the Steem account name which is associated with this Pocket account. A POCKET account name is considered valid if it adheres to the standard Steem account name specifications (i.e., in terms of allowed formats and characters).balance
: Non-negative integer storing the number of transferable POCKET tokens belonging to the account.
Throughout this document, the balance
property of an account named account
will be referenced as account.balance
.
Pending Confirmations
Send Confirmations
When a valid POCKET send
operation is executed, information about the operation is temporarily stored as a pending_confirmation
. This information is then posted by a third-party back to the Steem blockchain as a means to confirm to the sender that the operation was successful, and provide some useful information. A pending_confirmation
has the following properties:
identifier
: "@author/permlink" string associated with the Steem post which included the originalsend
command.amount
: integer amount of the originalsend
.from_account
: sending account.
to_account
: receiving account.new_from_balance
: Balance of sending account immediately after thesend
operation.new_to_balance
: Balance of receiving account immediately after thesend
operation.fee
: Fee reserved for the first account to post the confirmation information as a reply to the steem post identified byidentifier
.trxid
: The Steem transaction ID associated with the exactcomment
operation which contained thissend
command.
Claim Confirmations
After a Steem account claims their POCKET stake during the genesis interval, they can request a confirmation that their stake was claimed. This is done by replying to the Genesis Post with a single word "confirm", as described later in this document. When this is done, the POCKET database must again record that a confirmation has been requested until the intended confirmation is posted. A genesis confirmation requires much less information to be stored than a send confirmation:
identifier
: "@author/permlink" string associated with the Steem post which included the originalconfirm
command.account
: account that requested genesis confirmationfee
: Fee reserved for the first account to post the confirmation information as a reply to the steem post identified byidentifier
.trxid
: The Steem transaction ID associated with the exactcomment
operation which contained thisconfirm
command.
DB Activity State and Eligible accounts
At Steem block 1, POCKET is initialized to be inactive. When inactive, there exist no POCKET tokens, and thus no transfers are possible. Nonetheless, the Steem blockchain is still scanned by the POCKET protocol. During the inactivity period, all Steem accounts are monitored to determine their eligibility to receive POCKET tokens in the initial distribution. An account is considered eligible
if, before POCKET activates, it has posted at least 5 comment
operations to the Steem blockchain. There is no bonus for more, and no partial credits for less. Every time a comment
operation by <author>
is posted to the blockchain, <author>'s
running total is incremented; when the total hits 5, <author>
is eligible. The total is not decremented if <author>
deletes a comment. Note that a comment
operation that edits a previously-published post is considered a valid comment
for purposes of eligibility. Votes, reblogs, follows, and any other type of transaction is irrelevant to determining eligibility.
Activating POCKET
POCKET becomes active when a special comment
operation is included in the Steem blockchain with these properties:
author = biophil
title = genesis-pocket
Once published, this post is known as the "Genesis Post." Users of POCKET will interact with it to claim their tokens.
Note that the title of this post can be changed later, but its permlink will always remain genesis-pocket
.
Miscellaneous
After an eligible account has claimed its POCKET stake, they may request exactly one confirmation of this stake. Thus, a list must be maintained of accounts that have not yet requested this confirmation.
POCKET Operations
An "operation" is defined as an interaction with the POCKET system that is accomplished by posting a comment (in most cases) to the Steem blockchain. These operations are designed in such a way that POCKET tokens can be transferred between accounts using nothing more than a typical Steem front-end such as steemit.com.
A "command" is (in most cases) defined as a string included in the body
of a Steem comment. A "command" is parsed to form an "operation", a message which is passed to the POCKET database for validation.
There are two special operations that are only associated with the first 14 days of POCKET, also known as the "genesis interval":
genesis
: This is a specialized operation that is executed only once by a single pre-specified account, and it "turns on" the POCKET system.claim
: This is how eligible POCKET accounts agree to participate in the POCKET protocol and receive their genesis stake of tokens.
Other than the two genesis-related operations, there are three core operations possible in the POCKET system:
send
: This operation allows the owner of POCKET tokens to send them to another Pocket account.confirm
: This operation allows the owner of POCKET tokens to request a confirmation that they claimed their genesis stake. Each POCKET account is allowed exactly oneconfirm
operation.confirmation
: This operation allows a database-maintainer to collect a fee for reporting the success of a POCKETsend
orconfirm
operation.
genesis
operation
The genesis
operation is executed exactly once ever. It is the signal to the POCKET database that POCKET has begun.
Command Syntax: The genesis
operation is executed when the genesis account (biophil
) publishes a top-level post with the title genesis-pocket
.
author = biophil
title = genesis-pocket
Validity: If the database is inactive, then the genesis
operation is valid. Otherwise, it is not.
Result: Upon execution of a valid genesis
, the database state is switched to "active." The set of eligible accounts is frozen, and the record of accounts with 4 or less total Steem comment
operations can be deleted as they are now positively confirmed to be ineligible.
The genesis account is granted a genesis credit (even if not technically eligible):
biophil.balance += 1000001
Finally, suppose genesis
was executed in Steem block number genesis_block_num
. Then a new field is added to the POCKET database called genesis_last_block
and initialized to the value genesis_block_num + 403200
. 403200 is the approximate number of Steem blocks that are processed in 14 days.
claim
operation
The claim
operation is special; it is the only POCKET operation that is executed by doing something other than commenting.
Command Syntax: To execute claim
, an account account
must reblog the POCKET genesis post. That is, submit a Steem custom_json
transaction with json
payload as follows:
["reblog",{"author":"biophil","permlink":"genesis-pocket"}]
Validity: The claim
operation is valid if:
- The Genesis Post has been posted already; i.e., the database state is "active."
- The
reblog
command is included in a Steem block with number less than or equal togenesis_last_block
. account
posted 5 or morecomment
operations before the Genesis Post was first published (that is,account
is "eligible" for genesis stake).account
has not executed theclaim
operation before.
Result: If valid, claim
results in a credit of the Genesis Stake to account
. That is, the following database update:
account.balance += 1000001
account
is now eligible to receive a single genesis confirmation.
send
operation
A send
operation executed by account from_account
has two arguments:
amount
: The number of tokens to be transferred.to_account
: The account the tokens are to be transferred to.
Command Syntax A send
operation is submitted to the POCKET system by including a specially-formatted Steem comment
operation into the Steem blockchain. Any comment
is eligible to contain a send
operation if its body
begins with
pocketsend:amount@to_account
For example, if I want to send 1000 POCKET to account biophil
, I post a comment (either top-level or reply to some other post) to Steem with body
="pocketsend:1000@biophil" (where the quotation marks " indicate that this is a string, but are not to be included in the body itself).
Additionally, if a comma (",") is included immediately following to_account
, everything following the comma is considered a "memo" and is not parsed by the POCKET validator. For example, the above command is equivalent to
pocketsend:1000@biophil,this part is a memo.
If a memo is desired, the comma must be included and there cannot be a space between to_account
and the comma.
The proper format of a send
command can be verified by matching the post body
against the following regular expression:
^pocketsend:\d+@[a-z][a-z0-9\-.]{2,15}(,|$)
That is, "pocketsend:" followed by a non-empty integer, followed by "@", followed by valid account name, followed either by nothing or a "," and an arbitrary string.
In parsing the command, everything between the ":" and the "@" is recorded as amount
, and everything between "@" and "," or "EOL" is recorded as to_account
.
Validity: A send
operation is considered valid (with respect to the current database state) if and only if amount>0
and from_account.balance >= amount
. Note that POCKET does not check whether to_account
is actually a registered Steem account; this allows for the "creation" of POCKET accounts whose tokens are not currently spendable, but would be made so if someone registers the associated name as a Steem account.
Result: If a send
operation is valid, it results in the following database update:
from_account.balance -= amount
to_account.balance += amount - 1
- A new pending confirmation is added to the database, including the following information:
ident
: The Steem post identifier (that is,@accountname/permlink
) corresponding to the Steem post containing the original POCKETsend
messagetrxid
: The Steem transaction ID corresponding to the transaction in which the associated Steem post was included.from_account
to_account
amount
new_from_balance
: the new total balance of the receiving account, computed after the transaction (i.e., reflecting thesend
)new_to_balance
: the new total balance of the sending account, again computed after the transactionfee
: the fee reserved for the confirming account
confirm
operation
A confirm
operation executed by account account
has no arguments.
Command Syntax
A confirm
operation is submitted to the POCKET system by including a specially-formatted Steem comment
operation into the Steem blockchain. The comment
operation must have parent_permlink
equal to the genesis permlink (genesis-pocket
), parent_author
equal to the genesis account (biophil
), and the body
must be exactly equal to
confirm
.
Validity
To be valid, the following two conditions must be met:
account
must have claimed their POCKET genesis stake.account
must not have executed aconfirm
operation yet.
That is, you can only confirm after you claim genesis, and you cannot confirm more than once.
Result If valid, confirm
results in the following database update:
account.balance -= 1
- A new pending confirmation is added to the database, including the following information:
ident
: The Steem post identifier (that is,@accountname/permlink
) corresponding to the Steem post containing the original POCKETconfirm
messagetrxid
: The Steem transaction ID corresponding to the transaction in which the associated Steem post was included.account
fee
: the fee reserved for the confirming account
confirmation
operation for send
In the following, we will assume the database contains a pending_confirmation
object called pc
. A confirmation
operation associated with pc
executed by account confirmer
has these arguments:
identifier
amount
from_account
to_account
new_from_balance
new_to_balance
fee
trxid
Command Syntax
A proper confirmation
command is posted to the Steem blockchain as a reply to the post identified by pc.identifier
. That is, the confirmation
command is included in the body
of a comment with parent_author = pc.from_account
and parent_permlink
obtained from pc.identifier
. The body
of the comment, properly formatted, is given by (every line, including the last, ends with a linefeed \n
character):
Successful Send of pc.amount
Sending Account: pc.from_account
Receiving Account: pc.to_account
New sending account balance: pc.new_from_balance
New receiving account balance: pc.new_to_balance
Fee: pc.fee
Steem trxid: pc.trxid
The command is considered properly formatted if the body
of its associated comment
matches the following regular expression:
^Successful Send of \d+\nSending Account: [a-z][a-z0-9\-.]{2,15}\nReceiving Account: [a-z][a-z0-9\-.]{2,15}\nNew sending account balance: \d+\nNew receiving account balance: \d+\nFee: \d+\nSteem trxid: [a-f0-9]{40}\n
Note that any arbitrary string is allowed after the final LF \n
character, which allows confirmers to include other valuable information if desired.
Validity: A confirmation
operation op
is considered valid if there is a pending_confirmation
object pc
in the database to which op
exactly corresponds. That is, op
must meet the following criteria:
- The Steem transaction
op.trxid
must include thecomment
operation resulting in the associatedsend
command. - The command resulting in
op
must be in the body of a reply topc.identifier
. op.amount = pc.amount
op.from_account = pc.from_account
op.to_account = pc.to_account
op.new_from_balance = pc.new_from_balance
op.new_to_balance = pc.new_to_balance
op.fee = pc.fee
op.trxid = pc.trxid
Result: If a confirmation
operation is valid, it results in the following database update:
confirmer.balance += op.fee
- Pending confirmation
pc
is removed from the database.
confirmation
operation for confirm
The setup for posting a confirmation to a confirm
operation is much simpler. In the following, we will assume the database contains a pending_confirmation
object called pc
. A confirmation
operation associated with pc
executed by account confirmer
has these properties:
identifier
account
fee
trxid
Command Syntax
A proper confirmation
command is posted to the Steem blockchain as a reply to the post identified by pc.identifier
. That is, the confirmation
command is included in the body
of a comment with parent_author = pc.account
and parent_permlink
obtained from pc.identifier
. The body
of the comment, properly formatted, begins with (note that every line, including the last, ends with a linefeed \n
character):
Success! You claimed a genesis stake of 1000001.
trxid:pc.trxid
Note that any arbitrary string is allowed after the final LF \n
character, which allows confirmers to include other valuable information if desired.
Validity: A confirmation
operation op
is considered valid if there is a pending_confirmation
object pc
in the database to which op
exactly corresponds. That is, op
must meet the following criteria:
- The Steem transaction
op.trxid
must include thecomment
operation resulting in the inclusion of thisconfirm
operation associated withpc.identifier
in the Steem blockchain. - The command resulting in
op
must be in the body of a reply topc.identifier
. op.account = pc.account
op.trxid = pc.trxid
Result: If a confirmation
operation is valid, it results in the following database update:
confirmer.balance += op.fee
- Pending confirmation
pc
is removed from the database.
delete_confirmation
operation
It may happen that a POCKET user wishes to send tokens, but does not wish to pay the associated fee for the confirmation. If this is the case, the sender may execute the send
command in a post, and then immediately execute the Steem delete_comment
operation on the associated post. The original post's data will be included in the blockchain, so the send
operation will be considered valid, but because the post will have been deleted there will be no way to post a reply to confirm the send
. In this case, POCKET credits the associated fee to the receiving account.
Command Syntax: Every Steem delete_comment
, denoted del_comm
, operation must be checked for validity as a POCKET delete_confirmation
operation, denoted del_conf
. This operation has a single property, identifier
, which is equal to the identifier associated with del_comm
.
Validity:
Operation del_conf
is considered valid if there exists one or more pending_confirmation
objects in the POCKET database with identifier = del_conf.identifier
.
Result: If a del_conf
operation is valid, let pending_confs
denote the set of pending_confirmation
objects in the POCKET database such that for all pc
in pending_confs
, pc.identifier == del_conf.identifier
. Note that an identifier can be associated with more than one send
operation because the POCKET protocol does not distinguish between newly-posted comments and edited comments.
The result of del_conf
is
for pc in pending_confs :
pc.to_account.balance += pc.fee
delete pc from database
end_for
Note for confirm
operations:
All of the above applies as well for POCKET accounts who delete their confirm
posts. If a post containing a confirm
request is deleted before its associated confirmation can be posted, then the associated pending confirmation is also deleted. In this case, the fee is returned to the original account.
The POCKET Protocol in pseudocode
### Database initialization
DB.active = False
DB.eligible_accounts = empty # this will be populated with author account names
### Constants
C.GENESIS_ACCOUNT = biophil
C.GENESIS_TITLE = genesis-pocket
C.GENESIS_PERMLINK = genesis-pocket
C.GENESIS_CREDIT = 1000001
C.GENESIS_INTERVAL = 403200
C.FEE = 1
for STEEM operation op in block :
if DB.active == False :
if op is comment com :
if com.author == C.GENESIS_ACCOUNT :
if com.title == C.GENESIS_TITLE :
DB.active = True
DB.gensis_last_block = 403200
DB.GENESIS_ACCOUNT.balance += C.GENESIS_CREDIT
if com.author not in DB.eligible_accounts :
if com.author has posted fewer than 4 comments, add 1 to its comment count
else if com.author has posted exactly 4 comments, add com.author to DB.eligible_accounts
else if DB.active == True :
if op is comment com :
# watch for genesis confirmation requests and send transactions
if (com.parent_author == C.GENESIS_ACCOUNT) & (com.parent_permlink == C.GENESIS_PERMLINK) : # i.e., comment is a reply to the genesis post
if com.body == ‘confirm’ :
if DB.(com.author).needs_genesis_confirmation == True :
DB.pending_confirmations.add(confirmation info)
DB.(com.author).needs_genesis_confirmation = False
if com.body.startswith(‘pocketsend:’) :
if com.body parses to a send operation (to to_account) and com.author has sufficient balance :
DB.(com.author).balance -= send amount
DB.to_account.balance += send amount – C.FEE
DB.pending_confirmations.add(confirmation info)
# watch for send/genesis confirmations
if com.parent_identifier is in DB.pending_confirmations :
if com.body parses as the correct confirmation message :
remove this pending confirmation from DB.pending_confirmations
if op is delete_comment :
if deleted comment is associated with one or more pending confirmations :
for each associated send confirmation, delete the pending confirmation and credit the fee to the receiving account
for each associated genesis-confirm confirmation, delete the pending confirmation and credit the fee to the original account
if block <= DB.genesis_last_block :
if op is reblog :
if post being reblogged is genesis post :
if reblogger is in DB.eligible_accounts :
DB.reblogger.balance += C.GENESIS_CREDIT
DB.reblogger.needs_genesis_confirmation = True
pocketsend:1@postpromoter
Great experiment, thats what I like about steemit, lots of side projects that are built and building on the protocol.
I agree about this. Much project build on the right track
pocketsend:500@nicestbot, This is just a test
Successful Send of 500
Sending Account: rondras
Receiving Account: nicestbot
New sending account balance: 350
New receiving account balance: 499
Fee: 1
Steem trxid: 116f4ab6cc1ce5ad614542cefd0743c91453252a
Thanks for using POCKET! I am small bot and I am running this confirming code.
This is so freaking cool to see. Well done, Phil! I love seeing innovation experiments on the STEEM blockchain.
Thx, great idea, experiment.
Una traducción de lo esencial para la comunidad de habla hispana.
https://steemit.com/spanish/@rojassartorio/token-pocket-lanzamiento
¡Muchas Gracias! Leí su post y voy a enviar fichas.
pocketsend:1000@biophil
Successful Send of 1000
Sending Account: bless
Receiving Account: biophil
New sending account balance: 999001
New receiving account balance: 978658
Fee: 1
Steem trxid: 3f3ca1037e108e04b68f86817bba3128d03180c5
Thanks for using POCKET! I am running this confirmer code.
hi nice post very informative..
Successful Send of 1000
Sending Account: bless
Receiving Account: biophil
New sending account balance: 999001
New receiving account balance: 978658
Fee: 1
Steem trxid: 3f3ca1037e108e04b68f86817bba3128d03180c5
Thanks for using POCKET! I am running this confirmer code.
I'm still grasping what exactly a Pocket Token actually IS. Here's the closet thing I could find, if it could be translated into english:
Ok, so I have 1,000,000 POCKET Tokens. Now what? What can I do with them? @ironshield
At the moment? You can send them to someone else. I guess you could send them to yourself, if you're into that kind of thing. But we'll have to see what the community comes up with.
Oh, you could run a confirmer account like @pocket-a and collect fees. That's actually a pretty important thing to do with pocket.
I read your post announcing Pocket and it cleared things up quite a bit. https://steemit.com/pocket/@biophil/pocket-announcement
I'll be very interested to see how successful this experiment is and how far it goes.
Please continue to keep us posted.
Courtesy of @joshoeah
I was curious about something. You said the first account to confirm a transaction gets the fee. Right now that seems pretty straight forward but if it becomes successful and say there are 200 confirmers running a large number of them are all going to try to confirm at exactly the same time. So that would mean 199 useless messages posted to the blockchain or am I missing something there.
Yeah, that would be a mess, wouldn't it? Maybe by then we'll decide that pocket needs an upgrade to a better system.
Still new to the blockchain dev side. But when you create a comment, there is a function that calculates the permlink of the comment then you use it as part of the broadcast command. That permlink is a concaténation various metadata a time stamp. Maybe a solution would be to let the confirmer generate the permalink in such a way that any confirmation to the same send transaction is always unique: re-permlink-of-send-comment-confirmer. As permlink needs to be unique only the first who sends the confirmation would be recorded. Just a thought...
It's a good idea, but it's vulnerable to an attack that could totally shut down pocket: a bad guy could just reply to every pocket op with the reserved permlink and an empty comment, rendering the op unconfirmable.
Good point
Regarding replay from genesis. Would using something like SteemSQL or SteemData (MongoDB) helps with speed? We could query only posts that contains valid pocket op and process them. And instead of keeping an list of all users and their post count it can add them as it finds them in a valid post. After a replay it can use the blockchain directly.
I haven't used those services, so I don't know their capabilities. However, a query on posts wouldn't work because a single post can contain multiple pocket operations due to editing. You really do have to query the blockchain directly.
But if there is a service that lets you see something about what is in a block before you download the whole thing, that could be very helpful. For example, if a block is outside the Genesis interval and it contains no
comment
ops, then it's not relevant to pocket. That sort of thing.Also, you only need the first 30-40 characters of a pocketsend to check it it's valid. Don't know if that helps any.
I’ll investigate. I think there is a way to get the last version of a post. And maybe a way to get the block details by doing two calls, one to get a preview of the content and another one if we detect a comment op.