You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: If Hitler Had Won
I am talking with colonialism long before the war. They were still the same countries.
again. in case you missed it.
nagasaki
hiroshima
native americans.
"And if the "entire continent" was "exterminated", who are all these Africans living there today? "
The tribes were exterminated dude. The tribes. there are thousands of tribes.
"Fundamentally different from what the Germans did in WWII; once in control, the killing started. "
they controlled japan. look what they did. they controlled native americans. look wha they did.
go to bed.
You avoided the question about the USA's intention to kill all internees to make it comparable to what the Germans did.
So, they exterminated all tribes without exterminating all people? Interesting. I must read up on how they went about it.
I suspect, but don't know for sure, that the dropping of the atomic bombs was militarily unnecessary and therefore a war crime. Fact is, however, the USA didn't control Japan until after the surrender, and however much the Japanese were hated, few were intentionally killed after the surrender, once under control.
When they had the native americans under control, most killing stopped. Very un-Nazi-like.
Your comparisons still don't hold up.
I am far to old to go to bed at this time, but I'm starting to suspect you're not.
You see not all peoples on this planet belong to countries. Some belong to tribes and they are separated from one another.
"Control" can be many different things. USA controlled Japan. They just wanted to show power—much like Hitler, Mao, Lenin, you name it.
The comparisons are just fine. You are still avoiding the wiki page like the plaque. :)
intellectual dishonesty at its best yet from another "murica" man
I am removing my upvote from your post for this. You wrote an interesting article and gave good "food for thought", plus you did a good job defending your position. This last comment though is a personal attack directed at someone who is trying to present an alternative point of view, and is disrespectful and mean.
I didn't see you answering to any of my point while I dismantled yours...and now you are finding an excuse to abandon ship?
same applies to your friends. check the wiki page, open a book. something. i treat the WWII ally-war crime deniers much like i do the holocaust deniers.
sigh. pathetic human beings...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allied_war_crimes_during_World_War_II
Replying to your last comment here, due to the nesting level.
I thought you made good points, and I had no counter argument. I upvoted your post after you posted your reply to my comment.
Me removing my upvote has nothing to do with the arguments you made or whether your position is right or wrong. It is because of the way you are treating people who are responding to your post.
Good bye.
At least I am treating them linguistically...they deny war crimes.
i have no respect for people who are this ignorant