You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: 【Programming News】Qiitaまとめ記事 July 15, 2019 Vol.1

in #promari5 years ago

I see utopian-io tag, I see this post on utopian's review queue.. wasn't there a rule that 'utopian-io' tag must be the first one? Was this rule lifted? I might have missed that.

Anyways, are such "index listing" posts, acceptable in utopian-io? I see that promari has posted a lot (seriously, a lot) of tutorials, each of them probably could fit into utopian's "tutorial" category alone (but it was not), but.. THIS post doesnt.

Let's see https://join.utopian.io/guidelines/ "blog" category:

contain unique and insightful editorial content

doesn't apply

(1) Project Promotion, (2) Project Introduction, (3) Development Log

ok, with some leeway it might be "Project Promotion"..

Project promotion contributions must include author's personal experience with the project to be considered for potential reward. Blog post with information processed from official sites and materials, and with no additional value will not be considered for potential reward. General promotion posts about the project are not to be considered for potential reward.

doesn't apply

...and so on.

So, @promari, please, if you want to post under utopian-io tag, please carefully review https://join.utopian.io/guidelines/ and see the guidelines and hints listed there.

Mind that I am not an utopian reviewer. Since your post is on the review queue, an official reviewer will probably send a separate review, where they will review and score your post according to their judgement, and that judgement will be final. I think the official reviewer will agree with me, but I may be wrong, it's their call.

I am writing this comment to your post just to point you to the guidelines, so you might consider editing and improving your post to better match the guidelines for 'Blog', or other category, and to have better chance of passing the official review :)