You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Time To Wake Up and Fix Steem's Voting Problem

in #steem • 6 years ago

Your last sentence seems to indicate that witnesses could change the way this blockchain works. But so far it looks like they don't have this much influence. Do you really think they can?

6 years ago in #steem by
$0.03
  • Past Payouts $0.03, 0.00 TRX
  • - Author $0.03, 0.00 TRX
  • - Curators $0.00, 0.00 TRX
2 votes
Reply 10
Sort:  
  • Trending
    • [-]
     6 years ago (edited)

    The witnesses have to agree (or a percentage of them at least) for a hardfork to be a reality - they are the miners of Steem and they participate in discussions with Steemit inc. about what to do. You can vote for them in the right menu.

    Right now this representative democracy is not that well working - many people doesn't know how the system works.

    See this post: https://steemit.com/witness-category/@someguy123/seriously-what-is-a-witness-why-should-i-care-how-do-i-become-one-answer

    [-]
     6 years ago (edited)

    This only means that witnesses can block change, not that witnesses can actually implement change. In practical terms today, witnesses can't. Over time it is possible that development could evolve toward a more decentralized approach but there is at best only slow progress in that direction.

    $0.08
    • Past Payouts $0.08, 0.00 TRX
    • - Author $0.08, 0.00 TRX
    • - Curators $0.00, 0.00 TRX
    1 vote
    Reply
    [-]
     6 years ago 

    True. I just have to admit that. A veto is of course not representative democracy... That was just plain wrong - wishful thinking from my side.

    $0.84
    • Past Payouts $0.84, 0.00 TRX
    • - Author $0.83, 0.00 TRX
    • - Curators $0.01, 0.00 TRX
    1 vote
    Reply
    [-]
     6 years ago 

    I think we're on the same line. The chances are small the witnesses will some this. Looks like they didn't do anything as of I started with Steemit in January....

    [-]
     6 years ago 

    In my conversation with smooth the issue was apparent, most open-sourced projects field ideas and contributions from lots of people, but here steemit inc is the one that pushes ideas and code and it's a mostly closed process.

    [-]
     6 years ago (edited)

    Steemit inc can't force a hardfork without the witnesses agreeing. I found this old post by @someguy123 - it seems to sum up the basics.

    https://steemit.com/witness-category/@someguy123/seriously-what-is-a-witness-why-should-i-care-how-do-i-become-one-answer

    [-]
     6 years ago (edited)

    Not forcing a hardfork and open dynamic collaboration are very different things.

    $0.08
    • Past Payouts $0.08, 0.00 TRX
    • - Author $0.07, 0.00 TRX
    • - Curators $0.01, 0.00 TRX
    2 votes
    Reply
    [-]
     6 years ago 

    Well, this is very, very old in steemit terms, and some of the numbers referenced are outdated.

    [-]
     6 years ago 

    It is, but it does explain the concept of witnesses. For a more precise idea of the latest hardfork you should consult the white paper.