The FUNDAMENTAL issue of Steem nobody talks about... Part 1: Defining the problem (+ Bounty!)

in #steemit6 years ago (edited)

This is fine!

image.png
img src
Many steemians keep asking the same questions. Will Steem be more successful in the future? Will the userbase of Steem grow? Why, even though the count of steemians grows day-to-day, many people still haven't migrated from other platforms? What is holding down Steem?!
These people are passionate about our beloved platform. They prefer to concentrate on its advantages (100K TPS! Strong community! Decentralization!), not drawbacks. I was one of them. I believed that Steem's issues will be eventually addressed by developers or will be solved by community in a natural way. Some of the problems indeed are non-existent now: take spam posts, for example. Thanks to the HF20, spammers are now having a hard time continuing to produce their rubbish posts. Or Steemit website stability: I would say that it has vastly improved compared to the situation one year ago.
But one issue remains unresolved. This issue is often overlooked by steemians; to them, it does not exist. It was stealthy enough to hide from me for most of my wonderful journey on Steem; not anymore.

Back to basics

image.png
img src

The goal of every social platform is to get content delivered from the creator to the consumer. Steem only seems to meet this criteria. Let me explain.
Joe is an average Steemian (average Joe, heh). Because he is new at Steemit, he does not have a massive follower base nor has he any funds to promote his post. He creates a high quality post. He posts it.
What does he get in exchange?
Well...

  • His post is the first in the general 'new' section for about... 10 seconds;
  • His post is the first in categories' 'new' section for some minutes (hours?). Still, more time =/= more upvotes here, because the categories where posts are rarely posted usually do not have a large amount of visitors;
  • His post is displayed to his subscribers; unfortunately, if the subscriber has a large amount of subscriptions, chances are that he will never see Joe's post;
  • If he is lucky enough, his post will get to trending, but let's be honest - it has an extremely (as in <5%) chance to do it.
    Long story short, Joe's awesome high quality post will never get the appreciation it deserves.
    But wait, there's more!
    Steemit consists of thousands of such Joes, producing high-quality but severely underappreciated content. If every Joe managed to get his content to his potential readers, Steemit would be full of quality content.
    But Joes struggle to do this.
    Instead, Steemit is full of promoted posts. They are steling Joes' reader base. They are not giving Joes any chance.
    Yes, it is true that promoted posts can sometimes be really good (or really bad). But it's not the point.

The point is that Steemit's system of content discovery is flawed, which is the first part of the problem.

Simple answer to a big question

image.png
img src

We keep asking the same question: why are people not migrating to Steem?
The answer is simple: Steemit is not good enough. Head to Youtube (which, of course, is far from ideal due to the censorship). What do you see? Content consumers consuming content. Content creators getting views for their content.
Head to Medium. What do you see? Quality articles on relevant topics getting views.
Steemit is flooded with articles about its own ecosystem; it is sometimes hard to find original & relevant content using the tags. Talented authors initially not wishing to invest in Steemit's ecosystem (Joes) end up giving up and leaving Steemit. Their place is then being taken by (mostly) not-so-talented authors wishing to invest some money. In the end, Steemit's content quality level is lower than that of competing platforms, which makes me sad.

This is the second part of the problem: the amount of good and relevant content on Steemit is limited.

Note: by Steemit I also mean all of its interfaces, such as Partiko, Busy etc.
Note #2: you have the right to disagree, it is normal for human being to have its own point of view. Just try to be objective and think rationally before arguing.

To be continued...

Sort:  

@alexanderrigov has set 15.000 STEEM bounty on this post!
logo_for-light-bg_1000.png

Bounties are a new way you can earn rewards irrespective of you Steem Power. Go here to learn how bounties work.

Earn the bounty by commenting what you think the bounty creator wants to know from you.

Find more bounties here and become a bounty hunter.

Happy Rewards Hunting!

Loading...

Dear @alexanderrigov, you are talking about the problem of Steemit, where right now is not important waht you write but how much you invest.
The fairy tale of "make good contents and get rewarded" is no more valid after HF20.
I think the price of elite social is that, few users with huge SP, this is unfortunately the destiny of Semmit...:(((

Dear @intellihandling

right now is not important waht you write but how much you invest.

To some degree you're right. What matters is our investment, quality content and engagement (Which allows people to recognize us and that in return attract traffic).

The fairy tale of "make good contents and get rewarded"

And Im glad this fairy tale is not real any more.

Core of problem is not "tool" (steemit platform) but that general laziness and belief that quality content should promote itself.

I think we reached stage, where quality content is worth nothing if you do not engage with community. There is just to many content creators and most of them want to be "visible" without putting much effort to build their visibility.

Cheers,
Piotr

Dear my friend Piotr, you know that this sentence was write in Steemit White paper?
It Was my friend, because White paper Is now as toilet paper...☹️

Posted using Partiko Android

White paper Is now as toilet paper...

hahaha I cant stop laughint @intellihandling

Steem is a great platform but does not really compete with others. It might simply be the lack of advertisement or it needs a cool factor.

The coins logo is not as cool as Steemits logo for example. Facebook logo is simple and slick so is twitters. Making an account is also not as easy as making one on any other platform.

To get a free account people have to wait more than five minutes to get their account. People are not patient they want their product as quick as possible. The point of entry should be simpler. It should be as easy as making an account on any other platform.

Then there is the problem that people do not know what crypto is and might not care to learn what it is, get the coin, then pay in crypto to make the account quickly.

It is good that there is the option to make the account quickly but if the system excepted a debit card or credit card then converted it to steem it would be simpler for people to get their accounts.

I do not think people care about having to pay for the account we are a consumer economy after all. It is what means they use to make the purchase that confuses potential users which puts them off.

If people could also power up, buy steem or steem dollars with fiat that would be more convenient for them.

Maybe steem could partner with some service that provides this. Steem just needs a better medium between fiat to crypto.

Dear @cryptouno

What an amazing comment buddy.

Steem is a great platform but does not really compete with others

Small correction if you dont mind: Steemit is a platform :) STEEM = blockchain

Also Im not sure which other platform is doing better than Steemit. I tried many (if not all) and so far Steemit has the strongest community and building engagement here is way more efficient than anywhere else. But that's just my impression.

The point of entry should be simpler.

You're right here. I wish to understand why does it take so long to create account.

but if the system excepted a debit card or credit card then converted it to steem it would be simpler for people to get their accounts

This time I disagree.
Beauty of current solution is that it limits new users to those who understand basics of blockchain and crypto. I would never like it to be different.

Cheers
Piotr

I was comparing Steem to other social platforms like facebook, twitter,and Instagram. Everyone knows how to make an account on those sites.

I do not like facebook but they do have a large user base.

When the internet was first created people hated it. They thought it was too technical. Once the internet became easier to use it was adopted.

I was only thinking of ways to attract a larger user base since daily trading volume is only 3,127,729 coins.

Steem should have a higher trading volume. It is a great innovation.

Check out this Crypto Company. They are bringing Crypto to the masses.
https://steemit.com/kr-news/@cryptouno/pundi-x-the-crypto-between-worlds

I can go to a Coffee Shop in Hong Kong and pay for my sandwich and drink with my Crypto which is awesome.

I mean I can already do stuff online like booking airline tickets or pay for a hotel but I like how now I can go to a physical location and use my crypto.

Thank you @cryptouno for your great comment.

I figured that you're comparing this platform to Facebook. At the same time Im trying to correct you (hope you don't mind).

Because STEEM is not a social media platform. STEEM is a entire blockchain (public ledger). Steemit = social media platform.

STEEM and Steemit is not the same. Steemit (as a platform) is build on STEEM blockchain. So we can compare STEEM to EOS or other crypto. And we can compare Steemit to Facebook/twitter etc.

Hope Im making sense?

I was only thinking of ways to attract a larger user base

Very noble. I would be happy to help you if you would ever need my support.

And big THX for that link. Will check it out right away :)

Yours
Piotr

Also Im not sure which other platform is doing better than Steemit. I tried many (if not all) and so far Steemit has the strongest community and building engagement here is way more efficient than anywhere else. But that's just my impression.

Totally agree with you on this one. I would also add that no other decentralized media platform has such a great technology powering it.

Hello @alexanderrigov, hope you're doing well.

To be honest, it really is sad that quality posts really do get lost in the flood often, i've come across quite a few quality projects and posts that got overlooked due this issues, hope that changes soon.

Aside from that, i just wanted to say: Thank you!

I found out that you're one of the benefactors that helped back us up during the ''Santa Venezuela'' initiative, and i was happy beyond words when i received your help, and i'm sure each and everyone of those that received as well.

You're the best, thank you for your support!

I totally agree with you.
Good content are not getting the right recognition.
We have to be sincere high steem power holder are getting too much recognition.

Looking forward to the continuation of this post

Dear @oclinton

Good content are not getting the right recognition.

I think we reached stage, where quality content is worth nothing if you do not engage with community. There is just to many content creators and most of them want to be "visible" without putting much effort to build their visibility.

Core of problem is not "tool" (steemit platform) but that general laziness and belief that quality content should promote itself. Typical Joe is simply to lazy to build engagement with people and currate others conent.

Cheers,
Piotr

A very valid point you make. Currently the limited advertising interface steemit has, i.e. Promoted section, gets little to no traction and is actually seems to be a waste of resources. Advertising itself may not be the best solution.

I think what could potentially work is a goal orientated system that works like an automated tutorial system. Instead of encouraging newbs to post, it guides them to network, comment and connevt with people and gain followers, as soon as they unlock certain goals and followerships, post become available. They get rewarded for completing goals with posts and auto upvote from a whale account. Whales yo be paired with lower level accounts and to give at least 50 cent auto upvotes to sponsored accounts. Which is not much for them, but alot for lower level accounts. The higher rep the account gets to the greater the reward. Which will encourage users to constantly unlock new levels and goals. Kinda like a game.

Posted using Partiko Android

I think this is a great idea. 'Gamification' usually helps to motivate people.

Yes I agree.

There is actually lots of great content on steem, but it is impossible to find.

Fortunately I think this can be solved via UI.

If you have an Idea how, i would love to work with you on thinking about implementation.

I have a few ideas that I will express in my future post. I need some time to think how all of them could work; I will publish the post only when I feel like I have the concept ready.

P.S. Running out of Resource Credits :(

I love to see how responsive you are @alexanderrigov

I delegated 30 SP to you just now. It should help you with your RC. I will keep this delegation at least for 2-3 months.

yours
Piotr

Thanks a lot - your delegation really was a pleasant surprise! I am planning to buy some SP in the end of January. I think that you definitely can un-delegate me in February to help other Steemit authors which need SP more than I do.

All the best, Alex

Dear @alexanderrigov

you're very responsive which is absolutely great and steemit community surely will benefit by having you here.

if you would ever like to keep in touch and support each other closer, then drop me a message [email protected].
This will allow us to communicate easier.

No pressure of course,

ps. you mind telling me where're you from buddy? just curious.

Cheers, Piotr

if you would ever like to keep in touch and support each other closer, then drop me a message [email protected].

Sure, if (or rather when) I will feel that I can help you or someone else. My plan for 2019 includes investing in SP and Steem, and I hope that I will be able to help our community.

ps. you mind telling me where're you from buddy? just curious

I'm perfectly okay with answering this question, no need to excuse yourself :) I am from Latvia, but my mother tongue is Russian.

All the best, Alex

hi @alexanderrigov

so we're almost neighbours as I was born in Poland :)

hi @knircky

I think we reached stage, where quality content is worth nothing if you do not engage with community. There is just to many content creators and most of them want to be "visible" without putting much effort to build their visibility.

But most people do not understand that or are simply very lazy. You do create good content and Im reading it from time to time. But I do that only because I already know that you respect your viewers and engage with them.

Majority of users just want to post something they consider "good content" and they dont even bother to reply to comments. And soon after they lose their entire audience and start complaining about Steemit and blaming this platform.

Cheers,
Piotr

I post once a day, usually a #freewrite, which is a story written in 5 minutes, I would never expect to see it on the hot or trending thread. I create #freewrites because it's challenging and it relaxes me. Plus I make other #freewriters laugh sometimes. If the price of Steem goes up, it's just a plus. I'm here for the community involvement. Just my opinion. 🙏

Greetings, the problem at this point is well as a means that is not the most viable economic medium that a problem that is given as a problem that is distributed the pay one earns money, I speak as now the SBD is worth more than the STEEM , the page gives you only the lowest value currency, I speak that you do not even pay at least something that SBD, that at least pay a percentage of the coins here and another problem is this page would have better performance and allow you to see a chat people connected, so it would be easier to interact directly between users. The only viable thing that I have seen here are the initiatives that the same users invent to facilitate economic gains such as competitions, systems such as steem-bounty and many others, for now I see that the most viable thing here is to participate and integrate into projects that one find in steemit

Good point @ljmm.

Great comment. Anyway don't you think that to many people seem to expect that Steemit will solve problem of their posts visibility? It is simply not possible for every quality content to "pop up". One day we may have AI that will help to decide what is and what is not worth being displayed.

Yours
Piotr

I‘m looking forward for a great steemit Future! Good things always take their time to become great! So lets See, what 2019 brings!
Greets from LowerAustria, Robert