Good and Bad Comments - Learn How To Earn Upvotes And Replies For Appropriate Interaction
View this post on Hive: Good and Bad Comments - Learn How To Earn Upvotes And Replies For Appropriate Interaction
I have moved all my content away from the now centralized and controlled Steem blockchain to the decentralized Hive blockchain.
Great video @flauwy and you hit upon a topic rarely covered buy badly abused.
Of course, @ned made news for his $2K payout on a 5 sentence comment yet that is just the tip of the iceberg. I see so many who upvote themselves in the comment section yet do not upvote the post. What is interesting is rarely are the self upvoters of comments the ones leaving detailed, long, applicable comments. Those people usually post and let the community decide.
We really do need more attention given to this subject. I think you just inspired me to write a post about it....
Proper commenting and upvoting is really what separates those who are to be taken seriously from those who are not.
YOU are probably one of the most intense commentators on the entire blockchain. I see @abh12345's weekly analysis of the Stewards of Gondor and you are insanse with the length and frequency of comments - in a good way. How much time do you invest each day?
People are flocking to my posts because I am well known to upvote tons of comments every day. Not as high as @cryptoctopus but still more than the majority of all top Steemians. Of course that invites much spam but I see it as a game: Find the good and reward it, ignore the bad and punish the ugly. I think it works ok but it takes time for each user to get it.
Maybe the two of us should come up with an initiative to improve the situation particularly for newcomers. Right now I've got nothing but in a mutual creative process we could change the game for the entire blockchain. Combined with Utopian and they will call us king of comments for good reason soon enough!
I honestly do not know how much time I spend in here posting and commenting...but it is a fair bit.
Perhaps some would say I have no life... LOL
I look at it in the sense I am truly committed to this blockchain. One thing Reddit does have is there are a lot of commenters on there...or at least the ones that do comment leave valid ones.
One thing I noticed very quickly is that there were few comments on here. Most people fail to leave them. When each post averages 2.something comments apiece, that is horrific. Of course, part of the problem is the authors, themselves, do not reply.
I, too, upvote most of the comments. This attracts some attention although not all good. I have a core of people who are consistent, dedicated, and take time to read my stuff. However, like you, I get a ton of spam.
It is such a simple process...and many complain they cant write well enough to do articles...fair enough. But it does not take great writing skills to put together a few lines about an articles, especially if it is something that interests one.
I am game for that...hit me up on discord or steem.chat...I am same username on both although the discord is #9768
Alright, let's talk on Discord then!
Great job flauwy! Thanks for sharing... :)
Two ideas for you two, maybe it will help maybe not:
Quora app is being developed for Steem already. I haven't used it yet and I am not very interested in that kind of software, personally. I never was. But I salute it and every addition to Steem is welcome!
Very, very difficult to do. This goes beyond the Steem blockchain possibilities for now. it could be changed with a hardfork though! Something I have been complaining about since my first days on Steem. Maybe there IS a way to create a workaround for this. I have some ideas but it is complicated.
I like this strategy. It’s a good way to try and filter out the useless spam. It’s sad when someone posts something, expecting to get actual feedback (good or bad) and they get a fake comment instead, which is usually in the form of a compliment.
That's what a system like Steem invites as many people strife to receive money in form of upvotes. It gives the illusion of a fake community. However, this is just one of many layers and within is hidden the greatest gem mankind has seen during the technological revolution!
I agree the potential is inspiring! I still feel there is a long way to go. ...but it's def on the right path and worth it!
Not to change the subject but i just wanted to ask if your username was inspired by the marvel comics anti-hero that goes by the same name. I assume not because you have a kitten as an avatar and he is a skull faced assasin that can almost instantly assess and duplicate someones fighting style and then use it against them.
Never heard of that character but it looks AWESOME!
Oh he is awsome. He is one of my favorites
Thank you for sharing this!
Alot of people will see your videos and rush to make a comment so you will upvote. (because it is know that you are generous)
When I see your videos I click the like button 1st (I know you are sharing something good!) Then I watch entire video or read entire article. - THEN I leave a comment sometimes.
I also do not reward spam or fake comments on my page.
Side note thanks for all the support, I appreciate you.
Thanks, I do appreciate when people are honest like you. I know that many come to my posts because they know I will upvote a lot of comments. I think that is the least I can do since Steemit works that way and I find it sad when authors don't interact with their readers. However, I DO select the good (upvote and reply) from the bad (ignore and sometimes lecture) and the ugly (downvote).
Just one criticism: You should probably read/watch my content first before you upvote. You probably don't like it and just upvoting my stuff because you think it MIGHT be good is just a waste of your voting power in cases where you might disagree with me. ;)
I have the power to "remove my vote" and I'm not afraid to use it! lol
When I joined Steem you where one of the 1st people I noticed. With every video I LEARN something rather I "agree or disagree" is irrelevant to me.
I come here to learn, as long as you continue to teach, you will have my upvote. 👊
Well said! That possibility is always given and should be taken use of when required. However, you will loose the voting power and hence you can upvote less that day and you will have a small opportunity cost.
On the other hand with your strategy you are more likely to receive higher curation rewards because you upvote earlier. So there are two sides to the coin. :)
As an upvoter dont you make max curation money right after 30 minutes or have i understood that wrong?
Yes, before 30 minutes you get technically less curation rewards but even that depends on how much upvotes follow later. I can be still very profitable to upvote a mega post at 15 minutes or so because many others might do so between 15-30 minutes. It is complicated and confusing.
If I am understanding this correctly you are correct.
source
[Even tho I’m using delegated steem power. Thanks to @motoengineer!] I usually wait to upvote my comment to see if it gets a comment or if anyone else will upvote it first. To give back.
Other times if there are a lot of comments but I think mine is somehow relevant (a bit egotistical maybe) I’ll upvote it right after I post it. Reason is: I’ve noticed that comments with more upvotes get sorted to the top (I think it’s a setting but I haven’t really looked into it. 😇)
General comment @flauwy: Thank you for more informational and interaction-inducing posts!
I think your strategy is aboslutely fine and justified!
I appreciate your willingness to go in the open war with shallow comments.
I think that the issue is in the algorithm because it rewards mass production, not quality. Steemit has to find a way to gallantly reward exchange of thoughts and even confrontation or it will become a "plastic" hell far worse than it is Facebook today. And it will escalate quickly
Let's face it, the first Steemians are tech inclined people, not shallow, but can anyone imagine what it would be like one day when the majority of people from Facebook decides to come here. It will be mass production of nothingness in epic proportions and quality will be quickly overcrowded.
Thanks for the GREAT comment. I love the GIFs!
It is always the same: new users come and behave like zombies. This is a neverending story. But the community will regulate that by itself. I also made shitty comments in the beginning. It's a steep learning curve here on Steemit. You my friend will not have no problem to find freinds here. ;)
Thank you for your kind words. :)
Is thier a way i can resteem this and retitle it "How to be an absolute savage and eviscerate an entire comment section single handedly. "
Beautiful work sir.
haha, I am afraid you cannot resteem and change the title. Nice idea though. ;)
I love your comments by the way, they made my day. Keep it up!
I do what i can with what I've got. Thank you for noticing.
I notice most that is going on in my posts. And you are making a good impression recently!
Well thank you. I sm just trying to be me. I have only been here a month but it seems like there are an exorbitant amount of plastics and the bots really seem to take a lot of personality out of posts. I do love it here though. I told my father in law i was getting paid to be a smart ass. My perfect job. :)
There is a lot of room for smart asses here. :D
Thank you, interesting to see how an experienced steemian manages his upvotes.
I like that you reward genuine comments. I also like that you give constructive feedback to comments that you do not upvote.
I also enjoy the irony that a lot of people make generic comments to this video about not making such comments:D
Yeah, this has been the most entertaining thing I did in a while on Steemit. Because people behave so ironically. The cool thing is that we can all learn from this experience and become a tiny bit more repsonsible in our behaviour. The same goes for me as I learn to keep my calm and relax more when it comes to interaction. I had times when I was sad about getting tons of nonsense comments. Now I focus on the good and there luckily is plenty here.
Thanks for your comment!
Thanks for a thorough reply!
Yeah, rewarding genuine comments is a good way to reinforce good commenting. The carrot always beats the stick:)
I don't know about that. I'm not challenging any one with a stick to a fight if all i have is a carrot. You're crazy man.
How about two carrots?
That might work if you stabed them in the eyes and then made a snarky remark sbout how they are supposed to be good for thier vision.
Man, you are truly killing me today with your funny comments!
As proof i present 2 first place finishes. 1 for my daughter in her dance competition and the other for our race car in world of wheels car show. BOOM!!!! hard work pays off.
You would never think that i am in this giant building watching my daughters dance competition on one side of it then i walk across a tunnel where our race car is in World of Wheels car show all while still having time to entertain on steemit. This place is great.
Lol! I would go for this one:
Woah, is that a carrot-Zelda sword? SOOOOO cool!
Yap, it's powered up with carotene, Link's healthy choice:)
I'll be the first to admit that I never considered the amount of thought you put into reviewing the comments to that level of detail when I'm going through my own posts and reviewing the comments. That was informative for someone like myself still learning the ropes a bit around here.
I am not analyzing each comment like I did in the video. Most of it comes intuitive and you can see very quickly when a person put effort into it - like you! So here is your well-deserved upvote for a good interaction!
I always try to comment if it is in relation with the topic and the content, although I sometimes wonder if I am doing it right :)
Being daily active now on Steemit, I try to find my own rhythm on the community. So yes, not a fan of bots, spamming and replying with "great content, please follow me!" without reading the content.
For now I feel I improve week by week... I hope :)
With comments like this you are doing a good job. Upvoted!
I learned something ,do not upvote yourself.
I'm still learning here.how do you change your percentage on upvoting?
Learning the hard way :)
best regards,
Toddjr.
Hi Toddjr, thanks for writing a proper comment. You are in the vast minority so far. ;)
On Steemit you can change the voting weight only when you reach 500 Steem Power. However, when you use Busy.org, Chain.BB, Utopian.io and D.Tube instead of Steemit (they all run on Steem and share the same content and you need your private posting key which you'll find in your wallet under permissions) you get the slider for your voting power right from the start. :)
You can of course self-upvote yourself. Many do that. However, you should consider doing that only when it is approriate like when you want to push your comment to the top because you have an important question or addition to the post.
Wow huge help! also I saw your inspiring video for Utopian, tremendous value addictively I might add.
So I encourage you to do more promoting about Utopian, simply because of the awareness of the power of Steem,it really helped me.
Thank You Again..
Toddjr.
Helping others is a secret sauce for success on Steemit!
When I joined steemit, I met with the group of people who were playing upvote for upvote and comment for comment, I too start doing it with them, but then I realize it's a not good way to get noticed or to get success on this platform, Then i met a person @itwithsm, he told me how to get noticed and he told me commenting is the best way for you to get noticed in this platform, I'm not talking about the spam comment.
Then I start to examine it and yes it works. first of all, you need to understand the post, what message the author of the post is trying to convey, Analyze and then do a valuable comment :)
Thanks For sharing your valuable knowledge with us :) it will greatly help minnow to get noticed :)
I think many of did this silly mistake in the beginning. Me too. ;)
yeah, it is good to accept your mistake :) and try to never do it :)
That user comment with the 45 instant upvotes - I got it as well on one of my videos. I didn't really understand what was going on. Like you said, probably some kind of bot network.
These people are worse than the "good post" people. ;)