Luck Is a Matter of Perspective
A 35 year old woman walks down the street and a pot lands on her head. She is paralyzed from the neck down. For 5 years she goes through extensive physiotherapy until she gradually starts regaining basic functionality on her hands. 10 years pass and she can now starts taking her first steps. She was insured so she never has to worry about money ever again for the remainder of her life.
A child attends a dinner with his unemployed mother. At the dinner, the child gets bored and starts drawing a red sports car on a piece of napkin using his mom lipstick. The host of the dinner notices the child's doodle. It reminds him of his childhood when he too used to draw red sports cars. The host decides to hire his mother as his advisor. The child eventually grows up to become the CEO of the host's company. His success is short-lived since he dies tragically at the age of 35 from crashing a red sports car. He had a good life.
We can post these stories in a thousand online forums and host debates about which person of the two was the luckiest. People who value long livelihood and learning through life's struggles would consider the paralyzed women lucky. In contract, those who value a life full of excitement and fast rewards would appreciate dying from living one's dream.
People would create stories about how the boy's luck came to be and whether he worked on it. Similarly, some would even suggest that the woman having the pot landing on her head was nothing but a form of paying for the past sins. At the end, the narrative people will come up with will tell us more about them rather than what actually happened in the stories.
Nature, the host of our lives, does not care how we perceive luck. The concept of luck is nothing but an illusive narrative. A young couple might find a pregnancy a curse. The same couple, and after 20 years of trying, might find it a blessing. We like to talk about how we" make our luck" and how "if you believe in yourself anything is possible". We like to remember the times we truly believed in ourselves and made something amazing happen. The event will function as proof that our "mind game system" works. We will summon religion, spiritual forces and quantum events to justify our claim. Our brains will create its own narrative because it likes to forget the times we tried as hard but all those extraordinary events never took place.
Confirmation bias is the foundation of belief. It helps us go on in a world that is immensely chaotic. Without it, most people would end up depressed and/or suicidal. Biases, such as ones perceived as good or bad luck, blinds us enough to create a convincing narrative for our story here on earth. They fuse with our culture and so they provide us with something to hold onto. Luck is nothing but a matter of perspective. Our inability to rationally calculate the innumerable probabilities that govern our lives might also be the only thing that keeps (most of) us sane.
I'm a high school Maths teacher and while statistics is my least favorite part of the subject to teach I think it may be the most important.
I try to show how dishonestly presented statistics and probability can be used to fool you and how to look at situations and try to apply strict logical thinking to not get fooled.
A lot of sensational media and most politicians use humans inability to deal with these concepts instinctively against use, I like to think I help a like little to help students see through a lot of the bullshit.
Indeed. I think you will enjoy the book "Fooled by randomness"
Ah, one of my favourite books !
recommended to read it so many times now. and I have not got around to it, unforgivable, I know. will download it now and read it next
Yet another book on my reading list. I think it's very possible for it to skip most of the queue...
Have you heard of the trivium way of explaining things,I've only discovered this recently but found it very helpful to explainand understand certain things.
The trivium is the lower division of the seven liberal arts and comprises grammar, logic, and rhetoric (input, process, and output).[1]
The trivium is implicit in De nuptiis Philologiae et Mercurii ("On the Marriage of Philology and Mercury") by Martianus Capella, but the term was not used until the Carolingian Renaissance, when it was coined in imitation of the earlier quadrivium.[2] Grammar, logic, and rhetoric were essential to a classical education, as explained in Plato's dialogues. The three subjects together were denoted by the word trivium during the Middle Ages, but the tradition of first learning those three subjects was established in ancient Greece. Contemporary iterations have taken various forms, including those found in certain British and American universities (some being part of the Classical education movement) and at the independent Oundle School in the United Kingdom.The trivium is the lower division of the seven liberal arts and comprises grammar, logic, and rhetoric (input, process, and output).[1]
Grammar teaches the mechanics of language to the student. This is the step where the student "comes to terms," defining the objects and information perceived by the five senses. Hence, the Law of Identity: a tree is a tree, and not a cat.
Logic (also dialectic) is the "mechanics" of thought and of analysis, the process of identifying fallacious arguments and statements and so systematically removing contradictions, thereby producing factual knowledge that can be trusted.
Rhetoric is the application of language in order to instruct and to persuade the listener and the reader. It is the knowledge (grammar) now understood (logic) and being transmitted outwards as wisdom (rhetoric). @wikipedia
what does that have to do with anything?
also, it is bullshit. Krnel uses similar nonsene all the time.
Just because it is ancient, doesn't mean it applies.
Truth is a human construct and therefore subjective to interpretation and point of examination.
I like this
so many things are held up to be better just because they are old days.
Dara O'Briain an Irish comedian has a great stand up about old medical remedies
Here it is, it is towards the middle but it is all worth a watch
lol. had a good laugh with this one. nice one.
Great one! :D LOL!
O.k i get the point, have just watched Dara o'Brian giving some good examples. I,m new to all this but have the same problem when talking. Like a lot of people i sometimes say things out loud without really giving it any proper thought.
no need to apologize. We are all students here.
I can't say that came up in my teaching degree, it strikes me as something you hear in a power point presentation, with no real substance. But I will try give it a look.
The trivium is a just a structure of teaching. It does not apply well to luck or randomness.
It is a toolbox for analysing what happened, after it happened.
The most important thing about the trivium is comparing it to modern govern-cement schooling.
If you learn by method of the trivium, you start by reading all of the great works.
Then you are taught how to synthesize, put together the different thoughts.
Then you are taught how to express these thoughts to other is a convincing manner.
As opposed to modern govern-cement schools which start with rhetoric.
Or, they teach you what to think, not how to think.
This is what you call a deepity, just a complex one. It's just something that sounds deep and meaningful, but actually doesn't say much and doesn't have much value. What do rhetoric and grammar have to do with truth? Maybe a bit with teaching it, but not much.
@kyriacos
good post ,,, please come in my blog n follow back
Yeah read any of John Stossel's books and he will give you inside perspective and real life examples how media uses numbers and statistics to sensationalize issues for views.
While I don't believe in luck as a child of God, I do believe the God has given each us of the ability to deal with any and all things in life - good or bad. And, if we allow him, he always takes the lemon in our lives and make lemonade of it! So, I take great comfort in knowing that no matter what happens in my life that all things are working together for my good. To GOD be the glory!
Indeed, luck is not enough to bring people up the ladder of success and wealth. All the negative impression of other people's success actually creates a belief in our subconscious, that to be successful,
Generally, we think that luck is the key to a person's success or wealth. But apparently, luck will not last long if someone is not ready to accept it.
luck is again, a matter of interpretation.
This is exactly the reason I get so irked when people come up with their "everything happens for a reason" pseudo-wisdom after something unpleasant happens to them. There is no ulterior, grand plan behind why things happen, it is just your mind trying to make sense in hindsight out of an event that you perceived as negative – an effort to rationalize the random in order to gain some sense of control over the uncontrollable and unforeseeable.
Awesomely put.
Well, technically everything does happen for a reason...
It's just the reason is a cosmic dice throw of circumstances past and present combined with your current situation and the decisions made by you and everyone around you ;)
@pbock True, but I doubt that is what people who constantly use that set phrase have in mind whenever they utter it...
Yeah...
but its what we'll have in mind when we get so annoyed that we just need to shoot them down by seemingly agreeing with them, then explaining why their version is not what WE think 😈
It does not matter how long you live, important is how do you live your life. Some people have experienced more in 30 years than some in 2 lives
Quite accurate. Often longevity involves senseless copy-pasta of the same daily events.
I disagree, the length does matter from my perspective. One reason for us dying by disease is a lifestyle far from optimal and not aligned with nature, our great Mother! :) This of course affects the quality of life as well, it seems length and quality of life is connected as with most things.
Life's too short, and you never know when its goin
"At the end, the the narrative" - typo
Really like your footer! :)
"The concept of luck is nothing but an illusive narrative" , I think this sentences conclude everything about the luck itself.
Its shows that you must live your life as best as possible. Do all the thinhs you would like to do, do it now, don't wait till ,... later ?? Later could be gone earlier then you think ,..... nobody knows ,......