Experiential Traveling: Avoiding the Carnival Cruise

in #travel6 years ago (edited)

I'm traveling this week (not abroad, just to a different part of my home State) and have had a few thoughts about the spectrum of travel experiences in our society. I have felt for a while that traveling is an excellent way to learn. It facilitates an unusually powerful type of learning, based primarily on experiences, that can be difficult to replicate in traditional settings. In an increasingly connected, globalized world our ability to travel has improved dramatically over my lifetime alone.

While I deeply enjoy the experience, I'm also conscientious of the way I travel and how I act while traveling. As an American, I have traveled the world knowing that my presence can be acknowledged positively or negatively based on the current perception of my country. Unfortunately, politics can often dictate how people react to my presence. Moreover, I have done most of my travel (and all of my international travel) in a post 9/11 world, where I have experienced significant sentiment swings during my travels abroad during the United States' quasi-imperialist involvement in Iraq & Afganistan, during the globalization-focused Obama Administration, and, most recently, during the isolationist oriented Trump administration.

That said, I think there are some travelers, whether American or of a different nationality, that are received better than others. Traveling by what I call the "Carnival Cruise" method is an objectively shallow approach. I characterize this method of travel as a prepackaged set of experiences that apparently represents a complete picture of a society or travel destination. I chose the name as it analogous to the form of travel popularized by the cruise ship industry, but is not necessarily limited to this form of travel. One could experience Carnival Cruise travel during a trip to Iceland -- a nation rich in history and beaming with geographical diversity -- by simply visiting destinations such as Blue Lagoon, Reykjavik, and Gulfoss. Each location, in their own way, can be a great highlight of a trip to Iceland; however, it is a stretch to say that the trip is representative of all that the country has to offer. Alas, it is frequently considered to be such a comprehensive adventure.

This type of travel is misleading because it can make people think that they've experienced a new culture, society, geography, etc. when in reality they've only experienced a manufactured facade. Vitalik Buterin has made a similar comment during a podcast (Conversations with Tyler) when he stated that certain types of travel -- for example visiting just the Forbidden City in Bejing -- are better experienced through reading a Wikipedia article.

While Buterin may have been speaking in hyperbole, his comments resonated with me and are in many ways consistent with my own idealistic way of how people should travel. Yes, some travel, even if it's in the Carnival Cruise method, is better than no travel at all; that said, there are ways to learn a significant amount about a destination cheaply, efficiently, and without exuding a stereotypical American tourist presence.

I try my best to adhere to this philosophy in my personal travels and believe that it has yielded life-changing experiences. Specifically my time in South Africa, where I spent six months, I began to feel as if I were a member of the community (even if it wasn't felt by my ZA peers). I traveled with locals, lived with locals, and learned with locals in an attempt to learn by doing, not by reading or seeing a landmark. Writing this post has bubbled up feelings of nostalgia, so I'd like to share a few of my pictures. I think these pictures highlight some (definitely not all) of the vibrancy of this naturally spectacular nation.

I'd be interested to hear how others on Steemit approach travel and whether they have different views or philosophies.

Best,
Compass

P1010122.jpg!

P1000566.jpg!

DSCN0746.jpg!

P1040033.jpg

P1040798.jpg

IMG_3527.jpg

P1010309.jpg

IMG_3719 2.jpg

Sort:  

I upvoted you at 50% and invite you to #ccc.
I'll also feature you in a contest by @pifc.

All the best!

Thank you, @freedomshift I really appreciate the feature and your comments. I'm still new to #Steemit so happy to see my thoughts are thus far well received.

Thank you for upvoting. However, while you are new and have low SP, you contribute more with your comments and participation in communities such as @pifc and #ccc <<< please check us out.

Found you from @freedomshift's entry post to the Curation Contest. We for the most part try and keep our travels inside the US and try hard to get off the beaten path a little to see more then just the tourist traps as I call them. Heck we make running around the City of Chicago a vacation sometimes as there is so much to see there that even as a lifetime resident I haven't seen it all.

Thanks, @pifc! I think that's the right mentality. Personally, it has been all about perspective. In a city as dynamic as Chicago, I'm sure you'd attest to how dramatic a new route, path, or turn could make a previously known area feel unknown.

Keep wondering!

Hello there!

Very interesting reading.

I agree with you. I hate travelling in excursions. I usually go alone and without making plans... then I just walk the cities like the locals, to see what I find along the way.

I've found this post after reading @freedomshift's entry for The Pay it Forward Contest.


This post was shared in the Curation Collective Discord community for curators, and upvoted and resteemed by the @c-squared community account after manual review.

Hi I found you through an entry to the @pifc challenge by @freedomshift
I do agree there is such a rich experience to be had in traveling. It seems a shame to waste it by only scratching the surface.
I am always interested in getting acquainted with the people of different cultures or belief systems. I do enjoy to see the sights but for me the real delight is in the people. There is so much cultural diversity even in my area. I find that exploring those things many times will expand my own thinking.
Looks like you are getting the most of your travel time. South Africa looks like an extraordinary place to visit.

I found this post via @freedomshift's week 18 #payitforward contest entry promoted by @pifc. You have my upvote and follow, @marm16

Hello @marm16, your experiential travel is inspiring, living with the community and learn about their live and cherish the beauty of nature that artificial tourism destination couldn't give really exceptional. but.. I wondering what's the bilyard pole doing in the middle of the street? is that something usual or occasional? beautiful macaq.. how close you were to the macaq? all your pictures are stunning. thanks to @freedomshift who has featured you in his entry post for the pay it forward curation contest this week.

If I have a chance to travelling.. I would do the same as you do, I don't want to be a tourism destination reviewer, but I'd like to learn about how the community cherish their life and environment oo. Thanks for sharing this with us and wish you continued to write your insightful philosophy.

@cicisaja I'm really glad you enjoyed the read and hope that you can find the time to also travel in a similar fashion.

To answer your questions, the billiards table was in a busy market in a town outside of Durban, South Africa. We were wandering around that day and came across a really cool spice market as well... see below (sorry, for some reason the pictures keep posting sideways). I really like the pic because of its randomness, specifically its location and craftsmanship (see the ball catcher!?)

IMG_3715.jpg

The macaq was actually in a tree about 15-20 feet away, if I remember correctly. My camera is a Panasonic DMC-FZ200, which is a more user-friendly version of a traditional DSLR. Basically, I wanted the ability to zoom in on wildlife/scenery without compromising space in my bag with the additional lens.

I'm encouraged by your comments and will continue to post some of these photos!

Yaaayy... that's really cool @marm16.. don't worry about the picture, I can turn my phone up side down to see the pictures😊 OMG.. I never knew that Africa have many spices, the words is unique too.. how to read it? Forgive me, english is not my first language and there's a possibility that I confusing you with my comment😳.

No pretty photo of food aesthetic 😉 that's what a traveller should post. Exploring the unique things of a culture, wish you all the best @marm16... be healthy so you can do more travel and explore the world.

@freedomshift featured you in the Pay it Forward Curation Contest. what is what brought me to your post

What a spectacular post! I love having words for the way I've always felt...the Carnival Cruise method :) I hate that style of travel because it seems too often to only solidify the stereotypes of a country.

I found your post through @freedomshift's entry to our pay it forward contest. You are welcome to join us next week with an entry of your own :)

I'm also a member of @asapers and would love to have you join us. We focus on supporting quality unnoticed posts like your own here :) This is the invite link if you're interested. I know you're new here, so it's a good way to meet new people and new followers too!