You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Merge Rewards - Welcome GitHub Users: Withdraw in BTC, ETH and more! No STEEM Account needed!

Hey! Thanks for response.

Anyway... maybe you can discuss this with your moderator collueges

Actually I'm not a moderator :) Reviews from them are always formalized, have link to the scoresheet, and so on. I just sometimes go over current utopian-io activity to see what's going on, and sometimes I just feel like leaving a note when something feels odd (like recently, for example, https://steemit.com/promari/@promari/programming-news-qiita-july-15-2019-vol-1#@ookamisuuhaisha/pure8t - you have to admit it's ODD at the least).

I don't really understand why I should categorize this as "Ideas/Suggestions"

You're right. I must have been tired, now I reread your post and it doesn't sound like that. I think I was fooled by the "Here are two new ones:" in the middle of the post, and reading further I probably didn't notice that "Reducing Technical Debt" is a separate paragraph, and I took it as another point under "two more ideas". Sorry about that.

Regarding "linking to 30 commits", I get your point. I actually did something like that not long ago, closely following the guidelines, but .. I got scolded by the reviewers for getting into too much detail and producing too complex post. Well.. clearly the guidelines are not ideal then. However, I still think that for 'development' category, you should summarize the changes/features/etc. You've said now in your reply that

but actually most work lies in the paragraph "Seamless Onboarding"

I understand that now, but when I was reading your post, it was totally not clear! Nowhere in the text is any mention that you have just implemented that "Seamless Onboarding"! While reading this post, I was 100% sure that the "Onboarding" paragraph is just you promoting one of the main features of your project -- and that would exactly be the "Blog" category :) -- and that's why I thought that the actual work was on the "website desing" part.

If I were closely tracking your project, I'd probably get it that "Seamless Onboarding" is new feature, since previously it wasn't seamless, but .. for me as a random reader from the internet, it totally wasn't clear from the text of the post. Seriously, even changing the paragraph title to, for example, "New feature: Seamless Onboarding", or "Seamless Onboarding is now fully functional" would do the trick :)

Sort:  

Thanks for your genuine approach to help contributors with their posts! I like that! And yes, I will add another heading... Maybe Updates: ...
:D

Edit: Ok, updated the post. Should be more clear now. Thanks again for your feedback!