TOP 200 effective Steemit сurators that encourage discussion for the 2017.09.08

I want to share with you statistics about the most effective Steemit curators.

This statistic is not about how much the authors or curators have earned. This statistics shows the list of curators, whose contribution to the reward pool distribution is the most significant.

image source

---

What does this mean?

You can say that there is nothing interesting in this statistics. That it is clear that the reward pool is distributed by whales. But!

The most interesting thing is how the curator distributes the reward pool. He can vote only for his posts and his comments. He can vote for a selected circle of authors and affiliated accounts. But also he can vote for a large number of authors who publish interesting content.

Thus, an effective curator is a curator who has sufficient Steem Power (he can be an investor or a popular author who has earned his Steem Power by publishing interesting content), devoting time and effort to the content curating at Steemit and distributing a reward pool in favor of the authors. And the efficiency level is estimated by how much SBD curator distributes among as many authors as possible.

But this time we will review those curators who reward the discussions, that is, they vote for the comments of other users.

According to the ideology of the Steemit creators, the discussion is as valuable an element as the author's content. Confirmation of this is the allocation of a separate pool of awards for comments.

---

How it works?

Votes - Each curator distributes a certain part of the reward pool with his votes (upvote / flag).

Authors - This part of the pool he distributes between a certain number of authors.

VAS (vote average strength) - For general awareness, we can estimate the average vote strength in percents (%), with which the curator votes.

Contr. (SBD) (Contribution in SBD) - The distributed part of the pool is the contribution of the curator, it is calculated in SBD. In this case, the author's reward is taken into account. The curator's reward is not taken into account.

Share % - The percentage of the of the curator contribution among the contributions of all curators, we can also estimate for information purposes in %.

Eff. - The effectiveness of the curator is estimated in conventional units and is calculated as follows.

The total number of authors who published rewarded comments for the period under study is determined.
Then the contribution of the curator is divided by the total number of authors, and then multiplied by the number of authors for whom the curator voted for the period.

Thus, we see that, having distributed even a smaller number of SBD between a larger number of authors, the curator can be more effective than other curators. At the same time, having a greater voice power, but not actively voting, supporting a small number of authors, the curator takes a lower position in the rating.

And now, statistics.

---

4816 authors published their rewarded comments during this day.

5005 accounts participated in the comments curating according to information from the database.

43649 votes were made during this day.

4363,99 SBD - is the total author rewards for this day.

---

TOP-200 effective comments curators for September 8, 2017

№	Account	Votes	Authors	VAS(%)	Contr. (SBD)	Share %	Eff.
1	@surpassinggoogle	207	137	1	184,08	4,22	5,24
2	@good-karma	178	178	0	66,85	1,53	2,47
3	@gentlebot	74	71	100	75,8	1,74	1,12
4	@jesta	1488	85	0	42,49	0,97	0,75
5	@thing-2	73	69	100	44,19	1,01	0,63
6	@broncnutz	80	63	6	40,71	0,93	0,53
7	@kaylinart	38	34	24	53,23	1,22	0,38
8	@randowhale	131	15	2	110,37	2,53	0,34
9	@randowhale1	99	15	2	90,4	2,07	0,28
10	@donkeypong	32	31	3	41,7	0,96	0,27
11	@alexbeyman	37	33	100	37,83	0,87	0,26
12	@simonjones	9	2	100	544,82	12,48	0,23
13	@pharesim	57	45	0	23,03	0,53	0,22
14	@mexbit	29	15	67	44,25	1,01	0,14
15	@adm	247	2	2	298,51	6,84	0,12
16	@esteemapp	174	174	1	3,43	0,08	0,12
17	@noisy	12	9	85	59,4	1,36	0,11
18	@bitcoiner	176	176	1	2,76	0,06	0,1
19	@awgbibb	40	37	10	13,28	0,3	0,1
20	@kevinwong	37	35	3	13,9	0,32	0,1
21	@gamer00	62	31	10	13,94	0,32	0,09
22	@timcliff	41	35	7	12,95	0,3	0,09
23	@craig-grant	4	4	100	93,08	2,13	0,08
24	@swisswatcher	178	178	1	1,83	0,04	0,07
25	@midnas-howler	24	23	5	13,9	0,32	0,07
26	@streetstyle	29	25	10	12,64	0,29	0,07
27	@canadian-coconut	19	16	2	20,22	0,46	0,07
28	@feruz	177	176	1	1,77	0,04	0,06
29	@deanliu	18	18	32	16,09	0,37	0,06
30	@nippel66	40	22	52	13,26	0,3	0,06
31	@tommyhansen	18	13	36	23,74	0,54	0,06
32	@stackin	55	50	2	5,01	0,11	0,05
33	@ackza	48	40	20	6,56	0,15	0,05
34	@cryptoeagle	48	29	52	7,71	0,18	0,05
35	@ramta	14	13	5	20,16	0,46	0,05
36	@mattclarke	30	21	37	11,8	0,27	0,05
37	@lichtblick	84	57	1	4,15	0,1	0,05
38	@matt-a	25	16	4	15,12	0,35	0,05
39	@vandeberg	5	5	50	35,52	0,81	0,04
40	@chance777	59	20	34	9,18	0,21	0,04
41	@exyle	20	17	4	10,08	0,23	0,04
42	@happymoneyman	40	30	7	6,93	0,16	0,04
43	@hilarski	35	32	12	6,73	0,15	0,04
44	@elyaque	41	40	3	4,51	0,1	0,04
45	@eric-boucher	48	22	14	8,13	0,19	0,04
46	@surfyogi	15	15	8	13,24	0,3	0,04
47	@teamsteem	14	13	2	14,88	0,34	0,04
48	@blocktrades	3	3	5	71,37	1,64	0,04
49	@moala	14	2	100	88,59	2,03	0,04
50	@mammasitta	38	36	8	5,45	0,12	0,04
51	@anu	26	26	6	5,44	0,12	0,03
52	@michaelstobiersk	54	41	47	3,58	0,08	0,03
53	@asmolokalo	18	12	100	13,06	0,3	0,03
54	@tipu	32	12	26	10,45	0,24	0,03
55	@thecryptofiend	39	36	2	3,92	0,09	0,03
56	@xiknybuc	8	4	100	32,94	0,75	0,03
57	@floridasnail	39	30	15	4,28	0,1	0,03
58	@carterx7	23	17	28	9,67	0,22	0,03
59	@dyuryul	20	17	5	7,56	0,17	0,03
60	@xpilar	41	19	4	6,49	0,15	0,03
61	@extrospect	7	1	100	121,2	2,78	0,03
62	@paco	28	8	48	18,03	0,41	0,03
63	@everittdmickey	50	22	9	5,52	0,13	0,03
64	@hanshotfirst	28	26	1	4,71	0,11	0,03
65	@creadordelfuturo	30	23	5	5,71	0,13	0,03
66	@jaytop	27	26	28	6,14	0,14	0,03
67	@dragosroua	33	30	10	3	0,07	0,02
68	@rebeccaryan	17	15	25	5,28	0,12	0,02
69	@bubke	15	14	49	6,83	0,16	0,02
70	@jwolf	24	24	2	4,23	0,1	0,02
71	@lyndsaybowes	22	15	8	7,16	0,16	0,02
72	@roadscape	3	3	12	30,24	0,69	0,02
73	@uwelang	36	27	11	4,22	0,1	0,02
74	@barbro	22	15	9	6,85	0,16	0,02
75	@raybrockman	34	30	7	3,69	0,08	0,02
76	@cryptoctopus	9	9	5	8,1	0,19	0,02
77	@htliao	10	10	1	7,93	0,18	0,02
78	@overkillcoin	33	22	15	3,97	0,09	0,02
79	@ctrl-alt-nwo	31	17	1	5,13	0,12	0,02
80	@kafkanarchy84	27	22	9	4,64	0,11	0,02
81	@twinner	35	27	1	3,88	0,09	0,02
82	@libertyteeth	21	14	12	8,22	0,19	0,02
83	@steevc	57	26	6	4,44	0,1	0,02
84	@fulltimegeek	10	7	3	14,29	0,33	0,02
85	@ulfr	25	12	39	8,5	0,19	0,02
86	@onceuponatime	5	5	14	18,21	0,42	0,02
87	@davebrewer	12	10	27	11,04	0,25	0,02
88	@inventor16	29	24	50	4,1	0,09	0,02
89	@acidyo	9	9	1	9,55	0,22	0,02
90	@enki	10	10	4	3,44	0,08	0,01
91	@double-u	15	8	55	7,69	0,18	0,01
92	@camilla	6	4	52	7,36	0,17	0,01
93	@transisto	2	2	20	18,77	0,43	0,01
94	@greenjuice	24	22	5	1,98	0,05	0,01
95	@joeblack1	30	12	1	2,21	0,05	0,01
96	@lighthil	9	5	100	9,9	0,23	0,01
97	@riskdebonair	8	7	65	3,94	0,09	0,01
98	@quinneaker	32	25	4	1,63	0,04	0,01
99	@infovore	6	5	9	7,62	0,17	0,01
100	@elewarne	9	9	100	3,24	0,07	0,01
101	@rudystyle	10	1	100	43,46	1	0,01
102	@lightsplasher	9	8	47	7,04	0,16	0,01
103	@enomujjass	28	20	8	2,44	0,06	0,01
104	@nanzo-scoop	4	2	26	30,33	0,7	0,01
105	@richreck	14	9	66	4,31	0,1	0,01
106	@dexter-k	28	20	3	2,68	0,06	0,01
107	@dennisschroeder	20	4	100	12,36	0,28	0,01
108	@schamangerbert	24	19	6	1,76	0,04	0,01
109	@steemit-life	17	17	13	2,25	0,05	0,01
110	@stellabelle	2	2	100	24,7	0,57	0,01
111	@jiahn	73	28	30	1,54	0,04	0,01
112	@toktok	10	10	28	2,6	0,06	0,01
113	@meesterboom	40	27	1	1,62	0,04	0,01
114	@kus-knee	14	12	3	2,41	0,06	0,01
115	@klye	39	26	2	2	0,05	0,01
116	@lykencrypto	14	10	51	3,03	0,07	0,01
117	@enginewitty	37	22	10	1,33	0,03	0,01
118	@abh12345	65	38	11	1,2	0,03	0,01
119	@tjpezlo	16	11	100	2,78	0,06	0,01
120	@surfermarly	7	7	41	5,26	0,12	0,01
121	@diskorvery	8	5	38	7,45	0,17	0,01
122	@uplus	6	2	100	18,51	0,42	0,01
123	@travelwithus	52	34	35	1,44	0,03	0,01
124	@geronimo	17	5	79	6,3	0,14	0,01
125	@thedamus	33	18	44	3,91	0,09	0,01
126	@mynewsteemit	5	1	100	25,16	0,58	0,01
127	@boatymcboatface	8	7	10	5,1	0,12	0,01
128	@steemit-health	20	17	13	1,5	0,03	0,01
129	@britt.the.ish	11	1	100	39,24	0,9	0,01
130	@jerrybanfield	15	15	9	2,25	0,05	0,01
131	@khaiyoui	16	13	5	1,92	0,04	0,01
132	@inuk	28	1	100	26,05	0,6	0,01
133	@paolobeneforti	16	16	11	1,65	0,04	0,01
134	@greatpath	12	12	5	4,8	0,11	0,01
135	@ryanhkr	31	24	5	1,21	0,03	0,01
136	@d-pend	32	22	2	1,47	0,03	0,01
137	@arcange	2	2	3	0,06	0	0
138	@kayceesuave	1	0	100	0,01	0	0
139	@goofyu	4	4	100	0,64	0,01	0
140	@roelandp	1	1	1	0,29	0,01	0
141	@bareknowledge	2	2	100	0	0	0
142	@raphaelle	2	2	3	0,01	0	0
143	@forcesteem	1	1	100	0	0	0
144	@sauravrungta	2	2	100	5,64	0,13	0
145	@faranfani	2	0	100	0	0	0
146	@punzee	3	3	100	0	0	0
147	@chipnoreo	2	2	100	0	0	0
148	@pogoland	1	1	100	0,06	0	0
149	@bandana-gramma	1	1	100	0	0	0
150	@smetana	4	4	100	0	0	0
151	@irfanullah	1	1	100	0,01	0	0
152	@darksamus288	1	1	100	0,01	0	0
153	@alvorek	2	1	100	0,02	0	0
154	@gre3n	3	3	100	0,09	0	0
155	@andreacervantes	2	2	100	0	0	0
156	@tallyho	1	1	100	0	0	0
157	@catchup	1	1	100	0	0	0
158	@hot-girls	1	1	100	0,09	0	0
159	@disarrangedjane	5	4	100	0,05	0	0
160	@awesome-seven	2	2	20	0,08	0	0
161	@roncrowder	1	1	100	0	0	0
162	@alex-icey	1	1	100	0,04	0	0
163	@emmadetemmy	3	3	100	0	0	0
164	@kbcndh6b	2	2	100	0	0	0
165	@ibklimpak	2	2	100	0	0	0
166	@jokerpravis	1	1	100	0,26	0,01	0
167	@sanj	21	9	100	0	0	0
168	@madhatt	1	0	100	0	0	0
169	@rulesforrebels	2	2	64	0,18	0	0
170	@zx9c99	1	1	100	0	0	0
171	@killuminatic	4	3	55	0,25	0,01	0
172	@nationall	5	4	100	0	0	0
173	@nickmorphew	2	1	100	0,06	0	0
174	@talk2momz	2	2	100	0	0	0
175	@earnonlinewith	1	0	100	0,03	0	0
176	@rickyadiputra	1	1	100	0	0	0
177	@ali-butt	1	1	100	0	0	0
178	@leaving-egypt	3	3	100	0	0	0
179	@harryp3	1	1	100	0	0	0
180	@kriptofondas	2	2	100	0	0	0
181	@motivator	1	1	41	0,03	0	0
182	@li21	2	1	100	0	0	0
183	@rftube	1	0	100	0	0	0
184	@tom-stefan	1	1	100	0	0	0
185	@alktoni	3	3	100	0,31	0,01	0
186	@alexandrecseco	2	2	100	0	0	0
187	@lelek	1	1	100	0	0	0
188	@anubhavbhadani	1	1	100	0	0	0
189	@argd88	10	2	100	0	0	0
190	@rafalski	1	0	100	0	0	0
191	@africanlottery	1	1	100	0	0	0
192	@sift666	2	1	54	0,78	0,02	0
193	@necrophagist	5	0	100	0,39	0,01	0
194	@pcso	1	1	100	0	0	0
195	@davidstrohmer	1	1	100	0	0	0
196	@malonmar	5	4	15	0,2	0	0
197	@geneeverett	3	2	34	0,26	0,01	0
198	@biggeetx	1	1	100	0	0	0
199	@shyuan	4	4	100	0	0	0
200	@mesbaimicta	58	46	100	0	0	0

---

Now you know all these heroes. Their daily work increases the interest in the discussion, gives hope to some authors, and some even a decent income. Their work attracts new authors in Steemit and makes existing users remain.

---

Information sources

All information is prepared by querying data from a SteemSQL - SQL database containing information from Steem's blockchain, as well as by calculations based on this data.

Special thanks to @arcange for SteemSQL and for the advice provided to me during the development of this project.