You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: If Hitler Had Won

in #politics8 years ago

First of all, it is intentional deaths versus ill treatment in the Japanese internment. So, still an absurd comparison.

And yes, numbers do matter, especially when talking about the intentional killing of civilians versus collateral damage. The carnage intentionally caused by the Germans, and the reasons why, is comparable maybe to what Stalin, Pol Pot, Mao and the like did, but not to the Japanese internment or the political behaviour of "mosts governments".

No, most people in political power don't do what Hitler did. That is a nonsensical statement which only shows you haven't opened any history books yourself.

I'm not saying that I studied better than you, therefore you are wrong. I'm saying your facts are wrong because you haven't studied enough. You can't do critical thinking based on myths and folklore.

Sort:  

Go ask the japanese if it was "ill treatment" thousands died. Others vanished for secret experiments. what? do you think you would know if Hitler has won about the Jews?

By your definitions the means of some goverments justify the end. Hitler chose a path with no respect to human life. Americans did much the same. they did the same attrocities when it came to human experimentation (you see to conveniently by-pass this fact.

Hitler just killed more people and got more rep. Same exact attrocoties were done from the U.S, the Japanese, the Russians. really, almost all leaders. I actually dare you to find one case that it is not

I actually gave you links. You haven't provided shit yet

So, you are saying the USA had the firm intention to kill all Japanese internees? Because that is what it would take to make the two comparable.

Nowhere do I say that the means justify the end (sic), or the other way around, for that matter.

Hitler didn't "choose a path with no respect for human life", he intentionally killed millions. That is a different thing.

"almost all leaders"? No, a small minority of leaders, especially when talking about the 20th century, intentionally went out there to kill millions because of race, religion or politics.

I have no links to give you; the sources and literature I use take up 6 meters of my library wall.

Dude, they dropped 2 nuclear bombs. They treated them like trash. Everyone hated the Japanese much like they hated commies. Just the shallow evidence is overwhelming.

Here is a short link to remind you are "intentionally killing"

here is some more reading to add to your research:

https://www.darkmoon.me/2015/the-untold-story-of-american-war-crimes-in-japan-part-1/